
Updated November 2, 2026 · reading data through October 2026
The Hired Girl
by Laura Amy Schlitz
★ Top 5 book of 2015 · #2 on Best Books of 2015
In 1911, fourteen-year-old Joan flees her harsh farm life for Baltimore, where she takes a job as a housemaid for a Jewish family. Told through her diary, her story blends hunger for books and independence with humor, missteps, and a tender coming-of-age. Read the full description
Best for: Readers 12 and up who enjoy historical fiction and coming-of-age stories
The Hired Girl last appeared on BookWard's Top 100 in September 2026, at #94.
BookWard review of The Hired Girl
4 of 5 stars 4.2 out of 5, from 93 reader ratings
BookWard rates The Hired Girl 4.2 out of 5. That is the average of 93 reader ratings on Open Library (4.31), adjusted toward the typical book so that a small number of ratings cannot inflate it. Beyond the rating, 1,113 readers want to read it, 118 are reading it right now and 155 have finished it. Its adjusted rating is higher than 80% of the books on the Top 100.
How this rating works
BookWard’s rating is calculated, not hand-scored. We take the average rating readers have given the book on Open Library and adjust it toward the typical book: adjusted = (n × average + 25 × 3.8) ÷ (n + 25), where n is the number of ratings. A book needs at least 50 ratings to be rated. The rating reflects how readers received the book, not whether it is right for you. Your own ratings on your shelf are private and are not part of this number.
The Hired Girl on the Top 100: rank history
First charted in September 2026. The chart gains a point with every monthly update, so its peak, climbs and falls will show here as they happen.
| Month | Rank | Score |
|---|---|---|
| September 2026 | #94 | 49 |
Is The Hired Girl rising or falling?
Cooling It ranks lower this week than over the past year, so interest is softening from its recent level.
On Open Library, The Hired Girl ranks #154 this week, #149 this month, and #155 over the past year. A longer bar means a higher position. Comparing the three windows shows whether readers are arriving faster than the book's long-term pace. Readings as of 2026-09-30.
Why The Hired Girl made the Top 100
The Hired Girl made the list mainly on reader love (+17.3 points) and momentum (+16 points). Its smallest contribution is rising (+0.2). The BookWard Score blends five public signals, each scored from 0 to 100 and weighted as shown.
The reading-now, rating and rank signals come from Open Library’s public data, not from BookWard’s own readers. The score measures reading interest, not quality or sales. How the score works.
Open Library reader stats for The Hired Girl
Source: Open Library public reading logs, as of 2026-09-30. BookWard’s own monthly snapshots are added to the picture, and anonymous BookWard reader data will be layered in as the community grows.
More readers have The Hired Girl open right now than 9% of the other books on this list. These counts come from one public source, so they show relative interest rather than total readership.
About The Hired Girl
What it’s about
Joan Skraggs is fourteen, and since her mother died she has lived more like a servant than a daughter on the family farm outside Lancaster. Her father is cruel, her three brothers are sullen, and the one thing that keeps her going is reading. When her father announces that her schooling is over, Joan decides she has had enough. She runs away and takes a job as a hired girl at six dollars a week, finding out what kind of young woman she might become.
The story unfolds through Joan's own journal entries, set in the hopeful years before the First World War. It is a comedy at heart, full of a girl's hunger for Real Life and True Love, and it takes in questions of money, religion, social class, and the pull between romantic dreams and the plain facts of housework. Readers who love a spirited, bookish narrator will feel at home here.
At a glance
- First published
- 2015
- Genre
- Young adult
- Length
- about 400 pages (the median across its editions)
- Editions
- 11 on Open Library
- Setting
- Lancaster, America, Pennsylvania
- Characters listed
- Joan Skraggs, Joan of Arc, Miss Chandler, Father, Matthew
From Open Library and Wikidata public records. Missing rows mean the records do not list that fact.
Themes
- Coming of age in 1911
- Class and religion
- Independence
What reading it is like
Diary-style historical fiction.
At about 400 pages it is a longer read: roughly 8 hours at an average reading pace (about 250 words a minute, 300 words a page). Audiobook and edition lengths vary.
Good to know
Set in Baltimore in 1911.
The premise
A teenage girl from a hard farm life in the early 1900s leaves home to find work as a housemaid in a city household. Told in diary form, her story follows her hopes, mistakes, and growing sense of what she wants from life.
What you’ll get
- A lively, bookish narrator
- A rich historical setting
- Humor alongside heartfelt coming-of-age moments
You might skip it if you prefer contemporary settings or fast-paced plots over a character-driven historical story.
Pairs well with: Pride and Prejudice
Keep exploring the chart
The Hired Girl on the Best Books of 2015
The Hired Girl came out in 2015. Of the 55 books first published in 2015 that met BookWard's data bar, it ranks #2 on our Best Books of 2015 list.
Why it made the list: 1,389 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 4.3 out of 5 (94 ratings); 118 are reading it right now. The list ranks each year’s books on how many readers have picked them up, how highly readers rate them, and how many are reading them right now.
It earns Reader favorite and being read right now.
Nearby on the 2015 list
- Six of Crows Leigh Bardugo, #1
- Queen of Shadows Sarah J. Maas, #3
- November 9 Colleen Hoover, #4
See all Best Books of 2015 Best books by year
More years: Best Books of 2014 Best Books of 2016.
Questions about The Hired Girl
What rank is The Hired Girl on the Top 100 books?
The Hired Girl last appeared on BookWard's Top 100 in September 2026, at #94.
Is The Hired Girl rising or falling?
Cooling. It ranks lower this week than over the past year, so interest is softening from its recent level. On Open Library, The Hired Girl ranks #154 this week, #149 this month, and #155 over the past year.
Why is The Hired Girl on the Top 100?
The Hired Girl made the list mainly on reader love (+17.3 points) and momentum (+16 points). Its smallest contribution is rising (+0.2).
How many people are reading The Hired Girl right now?
Open Library's reading logs show 118 readers currently reading The Hired Girl, 1,113 who want to read it and 155 who have logged it as read (as of 2026-09-30). These are counts from one public source, not all readers.
Who is The Hired Girl best for?
Readers 12 and up who enjoy historical fiction and coming-of-age stories.
Ask a question about The Hired Girl
Ask about this book's chart history, reading interest, or who it is for. Answers come from this page's data and can be wrong.
Answers are AI-written from BookWard’s own help content and can be wrong. Please do not share personal information: questions and answers may be saved and, if they are useful, shown on this site without your name.
How we know
This page is built from public data: Open Library’s dated reading-log and ratings dumps, Wikipedia page views, Wikidata, and BookWard’s own monthly Top 100 snapshots. The interest rank blends shelf adds (45%), Wikipedia page views (30%), rating activity (10%) and, for months where a snapshot exists, BookWard’s own score (15%), each as a percentile among the Top 100 books. Every month shown is real data; nothing is estimated. Rankings reflect reading interest, not quality or sales, and can be affected by data gaps. Last updated September 2026. Read the full methodology.
Suits older children and teens, and adults who enjoy a warm period coming-of-age story.
400 pages, about 6.5 to 9.5 hours.
A runaway farm girl keeps a diary and finds her voice. 59% taste match
A runaway farm girl keeps a diary and finds her voice
Joan Skraggs is fourteen, has worked like a servant on her father's Pennsylvania farm, and has just been told she can't go to school anymore. The Hired Girl follows what she does about it, all through her own journal entries. The voice is where the book shines: Joan is vivid, earnest, bookish and very funny, and the diary form keeps her in every line. She is also a deeply drawn character, because her romantic notions and her real life keep colliding. The tone is comic, which is a pleasure, though it is gentler and warmer than the restrained approach I usually favor. At 400 pages it runs long for a reader who prizes tight books, but the middle never sags, because Joan's changing circumstances keep the pages moving.
At 400 pages it is longer than BookWard's taste for tight books, though the journal form breaks it into quick entries.
Short journal entries and steady changes in her circumstances keep things brisk, a touch gentler than BookWard's fast preference.
The period and diary format are not new, but Joan herself is fresh and specific, a little below BookWard's high bar.
Joan writes with a bookish, slightly ornate flourish that suits her, a bit richer than BookWard's plainer leaning.
What happens grows out of who Joan is, making this character-driven, a good fit for BookWard.
Joan escapes a harsh home and finds possibility, an uplifting arc that agrees with BookWard's mildly hopeful side.
The diary format is a distinct choice, though a familiar one, a little more formal than BookWard's usual conventional pick.
The book is billed as a comedy, and Joan's earnest self-dramatizing is genuinely funny, which BookWard enjoys.
Joan's cruel home is a shadow, but the tone stays gentle overall, lighter than BookWard's middle.
Joan's longings and hurts run hot but are tempered by humor, near BookWard's middling intensity.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
- Character depthBookWard 8 · book 9
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 7
Where it pulls apart
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 6
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 6
- OpeningBookWard 10 · book 8
At 400 pages it is longer than BookWard's taste for tight books, though the journal form breaks it into quick entries.
Joan's escape from the farm sets the story moving early, close to BookWard's preference for opening with a pull.
A runaway girl, a kind household and first love are familiar shapes, though Joan's voice keeps them from feeling stock.
Joan's choices follow from who she is and what she wants, so events feel earned, as BookWard likes.
Short journal entries and steady changes in her circumstances keep things brisk, a touch gentler than BookWard's fast preference.
The period and diary format are not new, but Joan herself is fresh and specific, a little below BookWard's high bar.
Joan is drawn in full, with her hopes, vanity and blind spots all on the page, which BookWard rates highly.
Joan's story reaches a real point of arrival, in line with BookWard's liking for resolution.
The book is warm and open-hearted, more sentimental than BookWard's restrained taste, though comedy keeps it from syrup.
The story earns its stakes through Joan's situation rather than cheap jolts, which BookWard values.
This is fiction, so the dial does not apply.
Joan's diary voice is the book's great strength, distinctive from the first line and exactly what BookWard prizes.
This is firmly story-led, following one girl's journey, with ideas about class and feminism carried by her experience.
Everything comes through Joan's own entries and scenes, close to BookWard's preference for showing over explaining.
Joan's shifting circumstances keep the middle moving, matching BookWard's wish for sustained interest.
Joan writes with a bookish, slightly ornate flourish that suits her, a bit richer than BookWard's plainer leaning.
What happens grows out of who Joan is, making this character-driven, a good fit for BookWard.
Joan escapes a harsh home and finds possibility, an uplifting arc that agrees with BookWard's mildly hopeful side.
The diary format is a distinct choice, though a familiar one, a little more formal than BookWard's usual conventional pick.
The book is billed as a comedy, and Joan's earnest self-dramatizing is genuinely funny, which BookWard enjoys.
The diary voice makes it easy to read, a little lighter than BookWard's usual middle ground.
Everything is seen through Joan alone, narrower than BookWard's taste for many viewpoints.
Journal entries move forward day by day, a straight line, more linear than BookWard's usual blend.
This is grounded historical realism with nothing fantastical, more earthbound than BookWard's usual spread.
A household of employers, family and neighbors gives a modest cast, in line with BookWard's smaller-cast leaning.
The story stays close to one girl and one household, more intimate than BookWard's middle position.
Joan's thoughts and feelings fill the page more than outward action, leaning inward past BookWard's middle.
Scenes carry real conversation, though the diary summarizes a lot, so it sits mid-range, below BookWard's heavier preference.
First love and sexual yearnings are a real strand of Joan's journey, giving romance more weight than BookWard's usual.
Rural Pennsylvania and its social world a century ago feel distinct, slightly more familiar than BookWard's taste for the unfamiliar.
The story is set in the years before the First World War, far from BookWard's present-day lean.
Joan's hunger for education and a life of her own is lasting, close to BookWard's liking for staying power.
Joan is sincere but sees herself romantically, so her account is not fully reliable, a bit under BookWard's unreliable pull.
Joan faces questions of class, religion and loyalty with some gray areas, but the book's sympathies are fairly clear.
Housework, hats and settings are rendered with relish in Joan's telling, richer than BookWard's usual middle.
This is fiction, so the dial does not apply.
Joan tells it in her own first-person diary, as personal as a book gets, far from BookWard's middle.
The Hired Girl is a standalone story, a touch more self-contained than BookWard's middle position.
The story moves by Joan's choices and discoveries rather than big reveals, fewer surprises than BookWard likes.
A warm, comic read that is more comforting than challenging, softer than BookWard's usual taste.
Joan's cruel home is a shadow, but the tone stays gentle overall, lighter than BookWard's middle.
Joan's longings and hurts run hot but are tempered by humor, near BookWard's middling intensity.
Joan's earnest self-seriousness gives the humor a gentle, affectionate edge rather than broad farce, near BookWard's middle.
Violence is minimal, with little on the page, lower than BookWard's middle.
First love and yearnings appear, but treated lightly and age-appropriately, below BookWard's middle.
Feminism, class and religion run through Joan's world without turning the book into argument, a touch under BookWard's middle.
The period voice is easy to follow, plainer than BookWard's middle position.
Joan's diary is full of strong opinions and judgments, more opinionated than BookWard's slight lean.
Set in a past era but focused on Joan's future, the book balances looking back and forward, near BookWard's middle.
Joan's faith in books, love and a bigger life gives the book an idealistic glow, in line with BookWard's lean.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is The Hired Girl right for?
Suits older children and teens, and adults who enjoy a warm period coming-of-age story. It touches on a cruel home life, first love and sexual yearnings, handled with care for young readers.
The diary voice makes it easy to read, a little lighter than BookWard's usual middle ground.
Joan's cruel home is a shadow, but the tone stays gentle overall, lighter than BookWard's middle.
Joan's longings and hurts run hot but are tempered by humor, near BookWard's middling intensity.
Violence is minimal, with little on the page, lower than BookWard's middle.
The Hired Girl: ideas, characters, themes
A fourteen-year-old farm girl runs away to claim an education and a life of her own, and tells us everything in her journal.
- A diary as a voice. The whole story comes through Joan's journal entries, so we see the world exactly as she does, flaws and all.
- Escape from a harsh home. Joan lives like a servant on her father's farm and is told she can't continue school, which pushes her to leave.
- Work and wages. Becoming a hired girl on six dollars a week puts the details of housework and money at the center of the story.
- Books as a lifeline. Joan's love of reading and education drives her choices and shapes how she understands herself.
- Comedy and longing together. The story is billed as a comedy, with Joan's search for Real Life and True Love played for both laughs and feeling.
Characters
Joan Skraggs
Narrator and heroine
A bookish fourteen-year-old who leaves her family farm to seek education and a fuller life.
Miss Chandler
Part of Joan's new world
A figure in the household and world Joan enters after leaving the farm.
Father
Joan's father
The cruel head of the family who forbids Joan to keep studying.
Matthew
Joan's brother
One of the three sullen brothers who share the farm with Joan.
Mark
Joan's brother
Another of the brothers who make Joan's life on the farm hard.
Themes
Joan's hunger to learn and to become more than the life handed to her.
How money, housework and social standing shape what a girl can do.
The gap between Joan's storybook ideas and the world as it actually is.
Joan growing into her own person through first love and hard lessons.
A young woman asserting her right to choose her own path.
Discussion questions
- How does the diary form change the way you trust Joan's account of events?
- What does Joan's love of books give her, and what does it cost her?
- How do class and money shape the choices open to Joan?
- Where does Joan's romantic imagination help her, and where does it mislead her?
- Why might the author have chosen comedy to tell a story about a hard start in life?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow The Hired Girl
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked The Hired Girl
A diary-form charmer that opens in a kitchen sink
When I Was Puerto RicanEsmeralda SantiagoA Puerto Rican girlhood, and the move that rewrote it
Pride and PrejudiceJane AustenA sharp, funny novel of manners that earns its romance
The Seven Storey MountainThomas MertonA restless young man's road from the world to a Trappist monastery
Track The Hired Girl and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.