
Updated November 2, 2026 · reading data through October 2026
One of Us Is Lying
by Karen M. McManus
★ Top 5 book of 2017 · #4 on Best Books of 2017
Five students walk into detention and only four walk out alive, and each has a secret. A twisty high-school mystery. Read the full description
Best for: Teens and adults who like whodunits
One of Us Is Lying last appeared on BookWard's Top 100 in September 2026, at #80.
BookWard review of One of Us Is Lying
4 of 5 stars 4.1 out of 5, from 97 reader ratings
BookWard rates One of Us Is Lying 4.1 out of 5. That is the average of 97 reader ratings on Open Library (4.14), adjusted toward the typical book so that a small number of ratings cannot inflate it. Beyond the rating, 2,575 readers want to read it, 152 are reading it right now and 140 have finished it. Its adjusted rating is higher than 51% of the books on the Top 100.
How this rating works
BookWard’s rating is calculated, not hand-scored. We take the average rating readers have given the book on Open Library and adjust it toward the typical book: adjusted = (n × average + 25 × 3.8) ÷ (n + 25), where n is the number of ratings. A book needs at least 50 ratings to be rated. The rating reflects how readers received the book, not whether it is right for you. Your own ratings on your shelf are private and are not part of this number.
One of Us Is Lying on the Top 100: rank history
First charted in September 2026. The chart gains a point with every monthly update, so its peak, climbs and falls will show here as they happen.
| Month | Rank | Score |
|---|---|---|
| September 2026 | #80 | 53 |
Is One of Us Is Lying rising or falling?
Holding steady Its weekly, monthly and yearly ranks are close together, so interest is steady rather than spiking.
On Open Library, One of Us Is Lying ranks #129 this week, #131 this month, and #252 over the past year. A longer bar means a higher position. Comparing the three windows shows whether readers are arriving faster than the book's long-term pace. Readings as of 2026-09-30.
Why One of Us Is Lying made the Top 100
One of Us Is Lying made the list mainly on momentum (+18.7 points) and reader love (+13.3 points). Its smallest contribution is rising (+4.2). The BookWard Score blends five public signals, each scored from 0 to 100 and weighted as shown.
The reading-now, rating and rank signals come from Open Library’s public data, not from BookWard’s own readers. The score measures reading interest, not quality or sales. How the score works.
Open Library reader stats for One of Us Is Lying
Source: Open Library public reading logs, as of 2026-09-30. BookWard’s own monthly snapshots are added to the picture, and anonymous BookWard reader data will be layered in as the community grows.
More readers have One of Us Is Lying open right now than 14% of the other books on this list. These counts come from one public source, so they show relative interest rather than total readership.
About One of Us Is Lying
What it’s about
Five students at Bayview High land in detention after a teacher finds cell phones in their bags, and each swears the phones were planted. Bronwyn, Nate, Cooper, and Addy are there, along with Simon, who runs 'About That', an app that spills the school's secrets. Simon does not leave the room alive. He suffers a fatal allergic reaction, and investigators soon find that he had prepared a post exposing something about each of the other four.
Now labelled the 'Bayview Four', the suspects are the brain, the beauty, the criminal, and the athlete. They begin warily, yet slowly grow closer while the pressure mounts. Told through the viewpoints of the suspects, this young-adult mystery is suspenseful and twisty. It asks how far people will go to protect their secrets, and how easily a label sticks. Karen M. McManus's debut spent five years on the New York Times list.
At a glance
- First published
- 2017
- Genre
- Young adult
- Also described as
- young adult fiction
- Length
- about 360 pages (the median across its editions)
- Languages
- editions in 8 languages listed on Open Library
- Editions
- 31 on Open Library
- Setting
- School
From Open Library and Wikidata public records. Missing rows mean the records do not list that fact.
Themes
- Secrets
- Teen pressure
- A murder mystery
What reading it is like
Fast, told by several narrators.
At about 360 pages it is a longer read: roughly 7 hours at an average reading pace (about 250 words a minute, 300 words a page). Audiobook and edition lengths vary.
Good to know
First in a series.
The premise
Five students go into detention and only four walk out alive. Each has a secret, and each becomes a suspect as the police investigate.
What you’ll get
- A twisty whodunit
- Alternating narrators
- High-school drama
You might skip it if you dislike teen mysteries.
Pairs well with: A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Keep exploring the chart
One of Us Is Lying on the Best Books of 2017
One of Us Is Lying came out in 2017. Of the 73 books first published in 2017 that met BookWard's data bar, it ranks #4 on our Best Books of 2017 list.
Why it made the list: 2,828 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 4.2 out of 5 (94 ratings); 149 are reading it right now. The list ranks each year’s books on how many readers have picked them up, how highly readers rate them, and how many are reading them right now.
It earns Being read right now.
Nearby on the 2017 list
- The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo Taylor Jenkins Reid, #2
- A Court of Wings and Ruin Sarah J. Maas, #3
- Why We Sleep Matthew P. Walker, #5
- The Dark Prophecy Rick Riordan, #6
See all Best Books of 2017 Best books by year
More years: Best Books of 2016 Best Books of 2018.
Questions about One of Us Is Lying
What rank is One of Us Is Lying on the Top 100 books?
One of Us Is Lying last appeared on BookWard's Top 100 in September 2026, at #80.
Is One of Us Is Lying rising or falling?
Holding steady. Its weekly, monthly and yearly ranks are close together, so interest is steady rather than spiking. On Open Library, One of Us Is Lying ranks #129 this week, #131 this month, and #252 over the past year.
Why is One of Us Is Lying on the Top 100?
One of Us Is Lying made the list mainly on momentum (+18.7 points) and reader love (+13.3 points). Its smallest contribution is rising (+4.2).
How many people are reading One of Us Is Lying right now?
Open Library's reading logs show 152 readers currently reading One of Us Is Lying, 2,575 who want to read it and 140 who have logged it as read (as of 2026-09-30). These are counts from one public source, not all readers.
Who is One of Us Is Lying best for?
Teens and adults who like whodunits.
Ask a question about One of Us Is Lying
Ask about this book's chart history, reading interest, or who it is for. Answers come from this page's data and can be wrong.
Answers are AI-written from BookWard’s own help content and can be wrong. Please do not share personal information: questions and answers may be saved and, if they are useful, shown on this site without your name.
How we know
This page is built from public data: Open Library’s dated reading-log and ratings dumps, Wikipedia page views, Wikidata, and BookWard’s own monthly Top 100 snapshots. The interest rank blends shelf adds (45%), Wikipedia page views (30%), rating activity (10%) and, for months where a snapshot exists, BookWard’s own score (15%), each as a percentile among the Top 100 books. Every month shown is real data; nothing is estimated. Rankings reflect reading interest, not quality or sales, and can be affected by data gaps. Last updated September 2026. Read the full methodology.
It suits teen and adult readers who enjoy fast, accessible mysteries.
360 pages, about 5.5 to 8.5 hours.
A detention-room death that makes four teens suspects at once. 60% taste match
A detention-room death that makes four teens suspects at once
A fast, plot-forward teen mystery that drops you into detention and kills off a character within the first chapters. The hook is immediate, and the question of who did it carries you forward. The pace is brisk, and the rotating viewpoints of the four suspects keep the middle from sagging. Character depth is decent for the genre, since each narrator carries a secret that could wreck their future, though they begin as recognisable types: the brain, the athlete, the outcast. Familiar tropes are the weak spot, with a Breakfast Club setup and gossip-app drama. What feels fresh is the premise rather than the archetypes. The emotional register stays fairly restrained, and the whodunit logic rewards close attention.
At 360 pages it is mid-sized for a thriller, longer than BookWard's tightest picks but moving fast enough to feel lean.
Short chapters and a ticking investigation keep things moving, in line with BookWard's fast-pace leaning.
The locked-room-in-a-school premise is fresh enough, but the character archetypes are familiar, falling short of BookWard's originality bar.
The prose is plain and conversational, serving the mystery rather than showing off, a bit plainer than BookWard's middle ground.
The whodunit comes first, though each suspect's secrets give the characters real weight, so it leans plot-driven.
The tone swings between suspicion and tentative friendship, landing near the middle on outlook.
Rotating first-person narrators add some formal variety within an otherwise conventional mystery frame.
Wry teenage banter lightens a serious situation, but the book stays mostly on the serious side.
A murder and exposed secrets give it an edge, kept within young-adult bounds.
Fear, guilt and shame run through the narrators without overwhelming the plot.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- OpeningBookWard 10 · book 10
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 8
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 4
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 4
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 7
At 360 pages it is mid-sized for a thriller, longer than BookWard's tightest picks but moving fast enough to feel lean.
A death in detention lands almost at once, which is exactly the kind of immediate opening BookWard rewards.
The detention setup and stock high-school roles lean on familiar teen-drama tropes, a step below BookWard's taste for avoiding them.
The clues and motives are built to be followed closely, so the puzzle mostly holds together, close to BookWard's preference.
Short chapters and a ticking investigation keep things moving, in line with BookWard's fast-pace leaning.
The locked-room-in-a-school premise is fresh enough, but the character archetypes are familiar, falling short of BookWard's originality bar.
Four narrators with real secrets get room to grow beyond their labels, though not as deeply as BookWard likes.
The mystery is resolved rather than left hanging, which matches BookWard's liking for closure.
Emotion is present but mostly kept in service of the plot rather than milked, a decent fit for BookWard.
The central death is a plot engine rather than shock for its own sake, though some reveals aim for impact.
This is fiction, so the rigor dial does not apply.
The teen narrators sound distinct from one another, though the voice is accessible rather than strikingly singular.
This is entirely story-led, driven by who did it, which sits close to BookWard's story-first lean.
Information comes through scenes, rumours and interrogation rather than lectures, matching BookWard's show-don't-tell taste.
Alternating viewpoints and fresh revelations keep the middle active, nearly matching BookWard's demand for sustained momentum.
The prose is plain and conversational, serving the mystery rather than showing off, a bit plainer than BookWard's middle ground.
The whodunit comes first, though each suspect's secrets give the characters real weight, so it leans plot-driven.
The tone swings between suspicion and tentative friendship, landing near the middle on outlook.
Rotating first-person narrators add some formal variety within an otherwise conventional mystery frame.
Wry teenage banter lightens a serious situation, but the book stays mostly on the serious side.
It reads easily and quickly, a lighter lift than BookWard's comfortable middle.
Four suspects each narrate, so the book is built on multiple perspectives, which BookWard enjoys.
The story moves forward in a straightforward sequence after the detention incident.
Everything is grounded in an ordinary American high school.
A handful of leads plus classmates, parents and police makes for a compact, manageable cast.
The stakes stay inside one school and community, so the scale is intimate.
Narrators weigh private worries alongside the outward hunt for a killer, balancing both.
Interrogations, arguments and teen banter make conversation a main engine of the book.
Relationships and attractions among the characters matter, but the mystery remains the spine.
A contemporary high school will be familiar territory for most readers.
The gossip app and constant phones place it firmly in the present day.
The social-media details tie it to its moment, though the central puzzle is evergreen.
The four narrators are mostly straightforward, with the suspense coming from what they withhold.
Secrets and loyalties muddy easy judgments about who is good, leaving some real ambiguity.
Setting and appearance get light touches, with detail kept in service of pace.
This is a novel, so the nonfiction style dial does not apply.
This is a novel, so the perspective dial does not apply.
It launched a series with two sequels, though the central mystery stands complete.
Leaked secrets and shifting suspicions deliver steady reversals, close to BookWard's appetite for surprises.
It is an accessible page-turner meant to entertain rather than unsettle.
A murder and exposed secrets give it an edge, kept within young-adult bounds.
Fear, guilt and shame run through the narrators without overwhelming the plot.
The humor is observational and teenage-dry rather than broad.
The central death is quick and mostly off-page, with little graphic violence.
Relationships and infidelity appear, but sexual content is mild for the genre.
Social pressure and reputation matter more here than politics.
The language is plain, contemporary and quick to follow.
The narrators carry strong teenage attitudes, though the book itself stays unpreachy.
It focuses on the present crisis, with students weighing futures that could be derailed.
Cynicism about gossip and image coexists with friendships that offer some warmth.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is One of Us Is Lying right for?
It suits teen and adult readers who enjoy fast, accessible mysteries. It involves a death, a murder investigation, drug-related trouble, infidelity and public shaming, handled at a young-adult level.
It reads easily and quickly, a lighter lift than BookWard's comfortable middle.
A murder and exposed secrets give it an edge, kept within young-adult bounds.
Fear, guilt and shame run through the narrators without overwhelming the plot.
The central death is quick and mostly off-page, with little graphic violence.
One of Us Is Lying: ideas, characters, themes
When a gossip-app creator dies in detention just before exposing four classmates' secrets, those same four become the prime suspects.
- A locked-room start. The story opens in a single detention room where five students are gathered, and one of them does not leave alive.
- Four suspects, four voices. The narration rotates among the four classmates tied to Simon's planned exposé, so we see each secret from the inside.
- Secrets as motive. Each student has something that could damage their future, which gives all four a reason to want Simon silenced.
- The media spotlight. The investigation draws public attention and labels the four, adding outside pressure to their private fears.
- Unlikely alliances. Shared suspicion pushes the students from distrust toward uneasy closeness as the case develops.
Characters
Bronwyn
The high-achieving suspect
A Yale-bound student who never breaks rules, now facing a secret that could threaten her college plans.
Addy
The homecoming princess
A popular, picture-perfect student whose private life is put at risk by Simon's post.
Nate
The student on probation
Already in trouble with the law, he has the most to lose if his secrets surface.
Cooper
The star pitcher
An all-star baseball player whose future in the sport could be derailed by an accusation.
Simon
The gossip-app creator
The outcast who runs Bayview High's notorious app and dies in detention before he can publish his reveals.
Themes
How hidden truths can be used as weapons and what people will do to keep them buried.
How a school and the public reduce people to types like brain, athlete or criminal.
The power an anonymous-feeling platform gives someone over other people's lives.
How fear divides people and how shared hardship can bring them together.
The weight of college, sports and family expectations on teenagers.
Discussion questions
- Which of the four narrators did you trust most at the start, and did that change?
- How does the gossip app shape who people think they are?
- Why might a teenager's secret feel life-ending even when it seems small to adults?
- Does the book treat the labels brain, beauty, criminal and athlete fairly, or just use them?
- How did the rotating viewpoints affect how you weighed each character as a suspect?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow One of Us Is Lying
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked One of Us Is Lying
A fast truth-or-dare thriller that brings Bayview High back
Good Girl, Bad BloodHolly JacksonA podcast-era sequel where a missing person pulls Pip back in
One of Us Is BackKaren M. McManusA fast YA whodunit that returns to Bayview for a third round
Double TakeCatherine CoulterAn FBI thriller that opens on a pier attack and keeps moving
Track One of Us Is Lying and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.