Cover of One of Us Is Back by Karen M. McManus
Young adult · first published 2023

One of Us Is Back

by Karen M. McManus

★ Top 25 book of 2023 · #14 on Best Books of 2023

The Bayview Crew returns home for the summer, hoping to move on from Simon's death, but a cryptic billboard announces a new game. When a friend vanishes, it becomes clear that old secrets are about to surface and everyone is a target.

Best for: Teen mystery readers who enjoy twisty, secret-filled stories and continuing a favorite series

One of Us Is Back is #14 on BookWard's Best Books of 2023, out of 34 2023 books that cleared our data bar.

Add to my shelf, freeSee all Best Books of 2023

#14on Best Books of 2023
52BookWard year score
242Open Library readers

What One of Us Is Back is about

Almost two years have passed since Simon died in detention, and the Bayview Crew is home for the summer, hoping to put it all behind them. They have already been through a lot: the original Bayview Four were forced to prove they were not killers, and a new generation later outsmarted a copycat bent on revenge.

Then a billboard appears reading 'Time for a new game, Bayview.' When one of the Bayview Crew goes missing, it is clear this is no prank. Bronwyn, Cooper, Addy, Nate, Maeve, Phoebe, Knox, Luis and Kris all have reason to worry, and someone unexpected is back in town. This is the third book in the series, so it is best read after the earlier ones.

One of Us Is Back on the Best Books of 2023

One of Us Is Back came out in 2023. Of the 34 books first published in 2023 that met BookWard's data bar, it ranks #14 on our Best Books of 2023 list.

Why it made the list: 242 readers have shelved it on Open Library. The list ranks each year’s books on how many readers have picked them up, how highly readers rate them, and how many are reading them right now.

Nearby on the 2023 list

See all Best Books of 2023 Best books by year

More years: Best Books of 2022 Best Books of 2024.

The numbers behind it

  • Readers: 215 want to read it, 10 are reading it now and 17 have read it, according to Open Library.
SignalThis book (0 to 100)Weight
Reach4455%
Reader love7925%
Being read right now4120%

Questions about One of Us Is Back

When was One of Us Is Back published?

One of Us Is Back by Karen M. McManus was first published in 2023.

Was One of Us Is Back one of the best books of 2023?

One of Us Is Back is #14 on BookWard's Best Books of 2023, out of 34 2023 books that cleared our data bar. 242 readers have shelved it on Open Library.

Why is One of Us Is Back on the Best Books of 2023 list?

242 readers have shelved it on Open Library.

More of the best books of 2023

See the full Best Books of 2023, the Top 100, or new books on Rising.

How we know

This page uses public data: Open Library reader counts and ratings, and Wikipedia page views for recent years. The description is paraphrased from real source text. Rankings reflect reading interest, not quality or sales, and can be affected by data gaps. Lists update monthly.

Who it is for

Suits older teens and adults who like YA thrillers, especially those who have read the earlier books.

Time to read

Depends on the edition you pick.

BookWard’s verdict

A fast YA whodunit that returns to Bayview for a third round. 49% taste match

Get it

Where to find it

BookWard’s take

A fast YA whodunit that returns to Bayview for a third round

This is the third Bayview mystery, so it leans on a series you need to have read. The setup is a good one: a billboard announces a new game, and then someone from the Bayview Crew vanishes. That gives the opening a real hook, and the genre promises a fast pace and a fully resolved ending, both things I like. The tradeoff is the familiarity. A secrets-and-threats teen thriller sits close to the formula, and the cast is large, with nine named teens to track, so character depth gets stretched thin across it. It also reads as part of a series rather than a clean standalone. If the first two books worked for you, this keeps the machinery running. If you want something fresh, look elsewhere.

Read it ifYou enjoyed the earlier Bayview mysteries and want another fast, twisty round with the same crew.
Skip it ifYou have not read the first two books or want a thriller that steers clear of familiar teen-mystery patterns.
Where this book sits on our ten dials
BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
LengthExtreme
Tight and shortLong and sprawling
PaceStrong
SlowFast
OriginalityStrong
FamiliarOriginal

A third entry in an established series built on a familiar formula gives little room for novelty, short of what BookWard prizes.

ProseLeaning
PlainOrnate

Plain, accessible language built for speed, far from BookWard's slightly richer midpoint.

DriveLeaning
Plot-drivenCharacter-driven

The central question of who is behind the game drives the book more than inner change.

OutlookLeaning
BleakHopeful

Dangerous but aimed at young readers, with friendship giving it a moderately hopeful lean.

StructureLeaning
ConventionalExperimental

Conventional thriller structure, moving forward from the billboard through the investigation.

ToneLeaning
SeriousFunny

Mostly tense, with the banter of teen friends offering only light relief.

ContentCentered
GentleDark

A disappearance and a threatening game add menace, kept within YA limits.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

Fear and loyalty register, but the tone stays a notch below heavy intensity.

See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book

Where it lines up

  • EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
  • OpeningBookWard 10 · book 9
  • PaceBookWard 8 · book 9

Where it pulls apart

  • Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 3
  • Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
  • OriginalityBookWard 9 · book 3
BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
Extreme 4 dials
LengthExtreme
Tight and shortLong and sprawling
OpeningExtreme
Slow buildHooks at once

A mysterious billboard and a disappearance set the game in motion straight away, which suits BookWard's love of an instant hook.

Familiar tropesExtreme
Leans on tropesAvoids them

Secrets, a game with hidden rules and a returning cast are well-worn teen thriller moves, which sits away from BookWard's tropes-averse taste.

Internal logicExtreme
LooseAirtight

Mystery plotting depends on clues fitting together, though teen thrillers often bend plausibility for the sake of the reveal.

Strong 11 dials
PaceStrong
SlowFast
OriginalityStrong
FamiliarOriginal

A third entry in an established series built on a familiar formula gives little room for novelty, short of what BookWard prizes.

Character depthStrong
TypesDeeply drawn

Nine named teens share the spotlight, so each gets less room than BookWard wants for deeply drawn people.

EndingStrong
Open, ambiguousFully resolved
SentimentStrong
SentimentalRestrained

YA friendship and loyalty carry some warmth, but the thriller frame keeps it from being overly gushy.

Shock for effectStrong
Leans on shockEarns its darkness

The danger comes from the game and the disappearance, with darkness tied to the plot rather than added for its own sake.

Rigor (nonfiction)Not applicableStrong
AnecdotalRigorous

Fiction, so this does not apply.

Authorial voiceStrong
GenericDistinctive

Brisk, conversational teen narration is readable and consistent but not strongly singular.

Story or ideasStrong
Story-ledIdea-led

This is entirely story-led, driven by the mystery and its escalating game.

ExpositionStrong
Shown in sceneExplained outright

A third book must catch readers up on past events, so some backstory gets explained directly.

Sagging middleStrong
Sags in the middleSustained throughout
Leaning 25 dials
ProseLeaning
PlainOrnate

Plain, accessible language built for speed, far from BookWard's slightly richer midpoint.

DriveLeaning
Plot-drivenCharacter-driven

The central question of who is behind the game drives the book more than inner change.

OutlookLeaning
BleakHopeful

Dangerous but aimed at young readers, with friendship giving it a moderately hopeful lean.

StructureLeaning
ConventionalExperimental

Conventional thriller structure, moving forward from the billboard through the investigation.

ToneLeaning
SeriousFunny

Mostly tense, with the banter of teen friends offering only light relief.

Reading effortLeaning
EasyDemanding

An easy, fast read with no heavy lifting, below BookWard's slightly demanding comfort zone.

ViewpointsLeaning
SingleMany

The series is known for rotating narrators across its cast, giving the story many angles.

TimelineLeaning
LinearShifting

Events unfold in the present of a single summer, with only backstory looking back.

RealityLeaning
GroundedFantastical

Fully grounded in a realistic small-town setting.

Cast sizeLeaning
SmallLarge

Nine named members of the Bayview Crew make for a large, interlocking ensemble.

ScaleLeaning
IntimateEpic

The stakes stay inside one town and one circle of friends.

FocusLeaning
Inner thoughtsOuter action

The pull is toward events and threats rather than long stretches of introspection.

DialogueLeaning
LightHeavy
RomanceLeaning
MinorCentral
SettingLeaning
FamiliarUnfamiliar

A recognizable American town and ordinary teen life, nothing unfamiliar.

EraLeaning
PastPresent day

Set in a contemporary, smartphone-era world.

Staying powerLeaning
Of its momentTimeless

A series installment tied to its genre moment, with limited reach beyond its fans.

NarratorLeaning
ReliableUnreliable

First-person teen narrators are generally straightforward rather than deceptive.

Moral clarityLeaning
ClearAmbiguous

Right and wrong are fairly clear, with the question being who is behind the game.

DescriptionLeaning
SparseRich

Setting and scenery stay light, serving the plot rather than slowing it.

Nonfiction styleNot applicableLeaning
NarrativeAnalytical

Fiction, so this does not apply.

PerspectiveNot applicableLeaning
PersonalDetached

Fiction, so this does not apply.

SeriesLeaning
StandalonePart of a series

The third book in the Bayview series, best read after the earlier two.

SurprisesLeaning
FewMany
Comfort or challengeLeaning
ComfortingChallenging

A comfortable, easy-going read for fans of the genre.

Centered 10 dials
ContentCentered
GentleDark

A disappearance and a threatening game add menace, kept within YA limits.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

Fear and loyalty register, but the tone stays a notch below heavy intensity.

Humor styleCentered
DryBroad

Teen banter and wisecracks lean lightly dry rather than broad.

Violence on the pageCentered
LittleA lot
Sexual contentCentered
LittleA lot
PoliticsCentered
AbsentFront and center

The story is about secrets and peril, not political issues.

Language difficultyCentered
PlainDialect or dense

Plain contemporary teen language, easy to follow.

NarrationCentered
NeutralOpinionated

Narrators have attitude, but the story does not push a point of view.

LooksCentered
BackForward

The book returns to events from the earlier mysteries while moving toward a resolution.

WorldviewCentered
CynicalIdealistic

Friends sticking together offsets the cynicism of a town full of secrets.

Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.

Age and content

Who is One of Us Is Back right for?

Suits older teens and adults who like YA thrillers, especially those who have read the earlier books. It involves a disappearance, threats and a death in the series' backstory.

BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
Reading effortLeaning
EasyDemanding

An easy, fast read with no heavy lifting, below BookWard's slightly demanding comfort zone.

ContentCentered
GentleDark

A disappearance and a threatening game add menace, kept within YA limits.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

Fear and loyalty register, but the tone stays a notch below heavy intensity.

Violence on the pageCentered
LittleA lot
Book Companion

One of Us Is Back: ideas, characters, themes

A mysterious billboard launches a new game in Bayview, and when a member of the Bayview Crew disappears, the group must work out who is behind it before things turn deadly.

  • A third round in Bayview. The story follows two earlier mysteries, and the crew is home for the summer trying to move on.
  • The billboard. A message reading 'Time for a new game, Bayview' signals that something has begun.
  • A disappearance. When a member of the crew goes missing, the game stops looking like a joke.
  • No rules. Whoever is in charge is not sharing how the game works, or whether it has rules at all.
  • Secrets surface. The story returns to the idea that secrets eventually come out, and Bayview has plenty it still hides.

Characters

Bronwyn

Member of the Bayview Crew

One of the named teens pulled into the new game.

Cooper

Member of the Bayview Crew

A returning character from the earlier books and one of the named targets.

Maeve

Member of the Bayview Crew

Part of the group the game threatens.

Knox

Member of the Bayview Crew

One of the named friends caught up in the mystery.

Themes

Secrets

What people hide and the sense that it will eventually come out.

Moving on

Trying to leave a painful past behind and finding it will not stay buried.

Loyalty

How a group of friends holds together when one of them is in danger.

Fear and control

Being manipulated by someone who sets the rules of a game and hides them.

Discussion questions

  1. Why might the author bring the same group back for a third mystery?
  2. How does the billboard change the way the town treats the game?
  3. What makes a disappearance more serious than a prank?
  4. How do secrets drive the plot of a mystery like this?
  5. Does a large cast help or hurt a story told from many viewpoints?
Made for you

Personalize your Book Companion

This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.

Personalize your Companion, free

Where to get it

Buy, listen or borrow One of Us Is Back

Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.

Find your own best books

Add what you have read, rate it, and BookWard will recommend what to read next.

Free to start. No credit card needed.