
One of us is next
by Karen M. McManus, Yaʻel Akhmon · 2020
It suits teen and older readers who like fast school-based mysteries.
384 pages, about 6 to 9 hours.
A fast truth-or-dare thriller that brings Bayview High back. 53% taste match
The story
One of Us Is Next is a young adult mystery thriller by Karen M. McManus, first published in 2020. It is the sequel to One of Us Is Lying and takes place about a year after the events of that book, at Bayview High School. The story follows three students, Maeve Rojas, Knox Myers, and Phoebe Lawton, who find themselves caught up in a game of truth or dare run by an anonymous texter. Players who refuse a dare can confess a secret instead, and they are given only 24 hours to decide. The stakes turn deadly as the game spreads through the school.
In the year since Simon's death, Bayview has seen a string of gossip apps come and go, and the new game seems meant to carry on his legacy. The novel sits within high school fiction, with friendship, secrets, and the pressure of a shared community as part of its setting. It runs to roughly 384 pages and has appeared in 14 editions. A further sequel, One of Us Is Back, followed in 2023, for readers who want to continue with the same Bayview characters and world.
Themes
New York Times bestsellerHigh school studentsHigh schools
- Want to read 594
- Reading now 33
- Read 41
Most people shelving it are saving it for later.
Of 668 readers who put it on a shelf, 89% want to read it, 5% are reading it now, 6% have finished it and 0% stopped before the end.
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 384 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 7.0 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 14 editions from 11 publishers, the earliest dated 2020 and the latest 2023, across 5 languages.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 1% of the recent books in our catalog (6,647 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Library of Congress class PZ-0007.10000000.M4637Or 2020.
A fast truth-or-dare thriller that brings Bayview High back
One of Us Is Next opens a year after Simon's death with a game that gives students 24 hours to dare or confess, and it hooks at once. Karen M. McManus keeps the pace quick and leans on a rotating trio of viewpoints, Maeve, Knox and Phoebe, so the opening grabs you and the story rarely lets up. The mystery is built to resolve, and the ending ties things off fully, which is a satisfying way to close a book like this. Where it falters is in leaning on familiar tropes: the anonymous texter and school secrets are well-worn ground, even when the game itself is neatly staged. The prose stays plain and dialogue carries a lot of the scenes. It also works as a sequel, picking up where the first book left off, though readers who skipped One of Us Is Lying will feel the gap.
At 384 pages it is a standard YA length, longer than BookWard's tight ideal but brisk in the reading.
Short deadlines and shifting viewpoints keep events moving, in step with BookWard's taste for speed.
The game concept refreshes the first book's gossip-app premise, but it still reads as a close sequel to a known formula.
The prose is plain and conversational, a touch simpler than BookWard's middle-leaning taste.
The mystery and the game drive events, with the characters reacting to it more than steering it.
The tone is tense rather than grim, with friendships offering some light in the situation.
It follows a conventional alternating-narrator mystery structure rather than anything experimental.
It is mainly a tense thriller, with only occasional teenage banter lightening it.
The game turns fatal, but it is pitched at a YA audience and stays moderately dark.
Fear and tension run high, while the emotional content stays measured.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
- OpeningBookWard 10 · book 9
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 4
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
- OriginalityBookWard 9 · book 4
At 384 pages it is a standard YA length, longer than BookWard's tight ideal but brisk in the reading.
The 24-hour truth-or-dare game gives the story an immediate engine, which matches BookWard's love of a book that grabs at once.
An anonymous texter and school secrets are familiar thriller territory, so it leans on tropes more than BookWard likes.
A mystery game needs its rules and reveals to hold together, and the setup is built to follow them reasonably well.
Short deadlines and shifting viewpoints keep events moving, in step with BookWard's taste for speed.
The game concept refreshes the first book's gossip-app premise, but it still reads as a close sequel to a known formula.
Three leads get real attention, though the genre's plot demands leave them less deeply drawn than BookWard prefers.
Mystery thrillers like this are built to reveal their culprit and tie things off, which BookWard rewards.
Friendship and loyalty carry some warmth, so it sits a little softer than BookWard's restrained preference.
The stakes turn deadly, and the darkness serves the mystery rather than being the whole point.
McManus writes in clean, teen-voiced narration that is readable but not strongly distinctive.
This is a story-led thriller, which fits BookWard's preference for plot over argument.
Backstory from the first book has to be filled in, so some explaining creeps in alongside the scenes.
The game's escalating dares give each stretch a reason to continue, so the middle holds up well.
The prose is plain and conversational, a touch simpler than BookWard's middle-leaning taste.
The mystery and the game drive events, with the characters reacting to it more than steering it.
The tone is tense rather than grim, with friendships offering some light in the situation.
It follows a conventional alternating-narrator mystery structure rather than anything experimental.
It is mainly a tense thriller, with only occasional teenage banter lightening it.
It reads easily and quickly, asking little effort beyond keeping track of the suspects.
The story moves between three main students, giving it more voices than a single-narrator book.
The story runs forward in a straightforward line from the game's first message.
It is a realistic high school thriller with no fantasy elements.
A school full of suspects and players gives it a bigger cast than BookWard's usual taste.
The action stays within one school and its students, so the scale is intimate.
Events and dares drive things more than introspection, leaning toward outward action.
Texts, confrontations and teen conversation carry a lot of the story, so dialogue is heavy.
Relationships are part of the story but share the stage with the central mystery.
A contemporary American high school is very familiar ground for most readers.
Gossip apps and anonymous texts place it squarely in the present day.
Its reliance on phones and apps ties it closely to its moment.
The narrators tell their own stories in a fairly straightforward way, so they read as reliable.
Right and wrong are fairly clear, though secrets and dares muddy individual choices a little.
Description is functional and light, serving the plot more than building atmosphere.
It is a direct sequel to One of Us Is Lying and is followed by One of Us Is Back.
Mystery thrillers like this are built around reveals, and the dares set up plenty of them.
It is a comfortable, page-turning read rather than a challenging one.
The game turns fatal, but it is pitched at a YA audience and stays moderately dark.
Fear and tension run high, while the emotional content stays measured.
Any humor is light, teenage banter rather than broad comedy.
Deadly consequences are part of the plot, but a YA thriller keeps the on-page violence moderate.
It is a YA title where sexual content is minimal.
The focus is on school life and secrets rather than political themes.
The language is plain and contemporary, with nothing dense to decode.
The narration stays close to its characters' views rather than editorializing.
It is rooted in the aftermath of the earlier book's events, looking back as much as ahead.
Friendship and loyalty offer some idealism against a backdrop of secrets and suspicion.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is One of us is next right for?
It suits teen and older readers who like fast school-based mysteries. The story involves deadly stakes and exposed secrets, which may unsettle sensitive readers.
It reads easily and quickly, asking little effort beyond keeping track of the suspects.
The game turns fatal, but it is pitched at a YA audience and stays moderately dark.
Fear and tension run high, while the emotional content stays measured.
Deadly consequences are part of the plot, but a YA thriller keeps the on-page violence moderate.
One of us is next: ideas, characters, themes
A year after Simon's death, a truth-or-dare game spreads through Bayview High, forcing students to confess secrets or face dares with deadly stakes.
- A game with a deadline. Players get only 24 hours to choose between a dare and a confession, which keeps the pressure on.
- A sequel set a year on. The story takes place about a year after the first book's events at Bayview High.
- Three main students. Maeve Rojas, Knox Myers and Phoebe Lawton are caught up in the game.
- An anonymous organiser. The game is run by an unknown texter whose identity is part of the mystery.
- Simon's legacy. The new game seems meant to carry on what Simon started, tying it to the first novel.
Characters
Maeve Rojas
One of the three central students
She is among the Bayview High students pulled into the truth-or-dare game.
Knox Myers
One of the three central students
He is another student drawn into the anonymous texter's game.
Phoebe Lawton
One of the three central students
She is the third lead caught up as the game spreads through the school.
Themes
What people hide, and the cost of having it exposed.
The choice between confessing and taking a risk.
How loyalty is tested when pressure rises.
How a past event shapes what happens next.
How a shared school setting amplifies gossip and fear.
Discussion questions
- Would you choose the dare or the confession, and why?
- How does knowing about Simon change the way the game feels?
- What makes an anonymous texter such an effective source of tension?
- Does the game punish dishonesty or simply cruelty?
- How well does the book stand without having read the first one?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow One of us is next
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked One of us is next
A fast YA whodunit that returns to Bayview for a third round
One of Us Is LyingKaren M. McManusA detention-room death that makes four teens suspects at once
Double TakeCatherine CoulterAn FBI thriller that opens on a pier attack and keeps moving
Good Girl, Bad BloodHolly JacksonA podcast-era sequel where a missing person pulls Pip back in
Sources: Open Library.
Track One of us is next and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.