
Updated November 2, 2026 · reading data through October 2026
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
by Holly Jackson
★ Top 5 book of 2019 · #2 on Best Books of 2019
A high schooler reopens a closed murder case for a school project and uncovers secrets in her small town. A twisty, young-adult mystery. Read the full description
Best for: Teens and adults who like whodunits
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder is #30 on BookWard's Top 100 books for November 2026, with a BookWard Score of 72 out of 100. It climbed 1 place from #31 last month.
BookWard review of A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
4 of 5 stars 4.0 out of 5, from 183 reader ratings
BookWard rates A Good Girl's Guide to Murder 4.0 out of 5. That is the average of 183 reader ratings on Open Library (4.03), adjusted toward the typical book so that a small number of ratings cannot inflate it. Beyond the rating, it is #30 on BookWard's Top 100 books; 5,928 readers want to read it, 375 are reading it right now and 287 have finished it.
How this rating works
BookWard’s rating is calculated, not hand-scored. We take the average rating readers have given the book on Open Library and adjust it toward the typical book: adjusted = (n × average + 25 × 3.8) ÷ (n + 25), where n is the number of ratings. A book needs at least 50 ratings to be rated. The rating reflects how readers received the book, not whether it is right for you. Your own ratings on your shelf are private and are not part of this number.
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: reading interest over the past 12 months
Sources: Open Library’s public reading-log and ratings data (dump of 2026-10-31), Wikipedia page views and Wikidata. Monthly counts are exact; they show relative interest among readers of these public sources, not total readership.
Ranked against the other books on this list, A Good Girl's Guide to Murder’s reading interest has run from #9 to #69 over these 12 months. Interest rank blends shelf adds, Wikipedia page views and rating activity, each compared with the other 99 books that month.
Shelf adds by month
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder was added to Open Library readers’ shelves 926 times in the past 12 months, peaking in October 2026 with 202 (162% above its monthly average of 77). Over the latest three months (Aug 2026 to Oct 2026) shelf adds were up 52% on the three months before. 87% of the adds were “want to read”, 7% “currently reading” and 6% “already read”.
Want to read Currently reading Already read
Wikipedia page views
Its Wikipedia article was viewed 296,231 times in the past 12 months, peaking in June 2026 with 77,587 views. The latest three months were down 69% on the three before.
Source: Wikimedia monthly page views for the article A Good Girl's Guide to Murder.
Adaptations
- A Good Girl's Guide To Murder (television series), 2024
Adaptations are listed from Wikidata; a release date near a rise in the charts above is context, not proof of a cause.
What the data says about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
- Moderate swings. Monthly shelf adds averaged 77 with some ups and downs.
- Busiest and quietest months. October 2026 was its busiest month (202 adds), about 5.9 times its quietest, December 2025 (34).
- Attention and shelf adds move independently. Its Wikipedia views and its shelf adds did not rise and fall together over these 12 months (correlation 0.01).
- Against its genre. It had 19% more shelf adds than the average Thriller and mystery book on this list.
- Share of the list. It accounts for 0.9% of all shelf adds recorded for the Top 100 over these 12 months, #37 of 100.
- Its age. First published in 2019 (7 years ago), it is older than 16% of the books on the list.
Each finding is computed from the public data above and shown only when the numbers support it.
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder on the Top 100: rank history
| Month | Rank | Score |
|---|---|---|
| November 2026 | #30 | 72 |
| October 2026 | #31 | 71 |
| September 2026 | #33 | 71 |
Is A Good Girl's Guide to Murder rising or falling?
Holding steady Its weekly, monthly and yearly ranks are close together, so interest is steady rather than spiking.
On Open Library, A Good Girl's Guide to Murder ranks #30 this week, #24 this month, and #43 over the past year. A longer bar means a higher position. Comparing the three windows shows whether readers are arriving faster than the book's long-term pace. Readings as of 2026-11-02.
Why A Good Girl's Guide to Murder made the Top 100
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder made the list mainly on momentum (+30.9 points) and being read right now (+19.9 points). Its smallest contribution is rising (+0.7). The BookWard Score blends five public signals, each scored from 0 to 100 and weighted as shown.
The reading-now, rating and rank signals come from Open Library’s public data, not from BookWard’s own readers. The score measures reading interest, not quality or sales. How the score works.
Open Library reader stats for A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Source: Open Library public reading logs, as of 2026-11-02. BookWard’s own monthly snapshots are added to the picture, and anonymous BookWard reader data will be layered in as the community grows.
More readers have A Good Girl's Guide to Murder open right now than 62% of the other books on this list. These counts come from one public source, so they show relative interest rather than total readership.
Where it sits among Thriller and mystery books
It is #2 of the 5 Thriller and mystery books on this month’s list.
About A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
What it’s about
Pip Fitz-Amobi is seventeen, a true crime enthusiast living in the small town of Little Kilton, Buckinghamshire. Five years ago, popular schoolgirl Andie Bell was murdered, and her boyfriend Sal Singh was widely believed to be the killer before he died by apparent suicide. For her school EPQ project, Pip decides to look again at the case, hoping to clear Sal's name and find out who was really responsible.
She gets unexpected help from Sal's brother Ravi, who is reluctant at first, but the further she digs into a town that thinks the matter is closed, the less welcome she becomes. Threats begin to arrive, and secrets that people have kept for years start to surface. Holly Jackson's debut is a fast, youthful mystery about truth, justice and what a community prefers not to know. It is the first of a series, and a six-part television adaptation was released on BBC iPlayer on 1 July 2024.
At a glance
- First published
- 2019-05-02
- Genre
- Thriller and mystery
- Also described as
- young adult fiction, mystery fiction
- Length
- about 431 pages (the median across its editions)
- Original language
- English
- Languages
- editions in 10 languages listed on Open Library
- Editions
- 38 on Open Library
From Open Library and Wikidata public records. Missing rows mean the records do not list that fact.
Themes
- Amateur detective work
- Teen secrets
- Media and justice
What reading it is like
Fast and twisty, told partly through project logs and interviews.
At about 431 pages it is a longer read: roughly 9 hours at an average reading pace (about 250 words a minute, 300 words a page). Audiobook and edition lengths vary.
Good to know
First in a series. Teen-friendly, but it deals with murder, drugs and assault.
The premise
For a school project, Pip reopens the case of a local girl's murder that police closed years ago. The more she digs, the more secrets she finds in her small town.
What you’ll get
- A twisty teen mystery
- Podcast-style investigation pages
- A clever, fast plot
You might skip it if you dislike stories involving violence and crime.
Keep exploring the chart
Also on the chart at #29 and #31
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder on the Best Books of 2019
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder came out in 2019. Of the 83 books first published in 2019 that met BookWard's data bar, it ranks #2 on our Best Books of 2019 list.
Why it made the list: 6,503 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 4 out of 5 (181 ratings); 371 are reading it right now. The list ranks each year’s books on how many readers have picked them up, how highly readers rate them, and how many are reading them right now.
It earns Being read right now.
Nearby on the 2019 list
- Red, White & Royal Blue Casey McQuiston, #1
- Heartstopper, Volume 2 Alice Oseman, #3
- Guts Raina Telgemeier, #4
See all Best Books of 2019 Best books by year
More years: Best Books of 2018 Best Books of 2020.
Questions about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
What rank is A Good Girl's Guide to Murder on the Top 100 books?
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder is #30 on BookWard's Top 100 books for November 2026, with a BookWard Score of 72 out of 100. It climbed 1 place from #31 last month.
Is A Good Girl's Guide to Murder rising or falling?
Holding steady. Its weekly, monthly and yearly ranks are close together, so interest is steady rather than spiking. On Open Library, A Good Girl's Guide to Murder ranks #30 this week, #24 this month, and #43 over the past year.
Why is A Good Girl's Guide to Murder on the Top 100?
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder made the list mainly on momentum (+30.9 points) and being read right now (+19.9 points). Its smallest contribution is rising (+0.7).
How many people are reading A Good Girl's Guide to Murder right now?
Open Library's reading logs show 375 readers currently reading A Good Girl's Guide to Murder, 5,928 who want to read it and 287 who have logged it as read (as of 2026-11-02). These are counts from one public source, not all readers.
How much interest has A Good Girl's Guide to Murder had over the past year?
926 Open Library shelf adds in the past 12 months (peak October 2026, 202); latest three months up 52% on the prior three; 296,231 Wikipedia views in the past 12 months (down 69% over the latest three months); Adaptations on Wikidata: A Good Girl's Guide To Murder (2024). Figures come from Open Library and Wikipedia public data.
Who is A Good Girl's Guide to Murder best for?
Teens and adults who like whodunits.
Ask a question about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Ask about this book's chart history, reading interest, or who it is for. Answers come from this page's data and can be wrong.
Answers are AI-written from BookWard’s own help content and can be wrong. Please do not share personal information: questions and answers may be saved and, if they are useful, shown on this site without your name.
How we know
This page is built from public data: Open Library’s dated reading-log and ratings dumps, Wikipedia page views, Wikidata, and BookWard’s own monthly Top 100 snapshots. The interest rank blends shelf adds (45%), Wikipedia page views (30%), rating activity (10%) and, for months where a snapshot exists, BookWard’s own score (15%), each as a percentile among the Top 100 books. Every month shown is real data; nothing is estimated. Rankings reflect reading interest, not quality or sales, and can be affected by data gaps. Last updated November 2026. Read the full methodology.
Suited to teens and adult readers of mystery.
431 pages, about 7 to 10 hours.
A teen true-crime fan reopens a murder case for school. 53% taste match
A teen true-crime fan reopens a murder case for school
Holly Jackson's 2019 debut hands a seventeen-year-old true crime fan a school project and a five-year-old murder that the whole town considers solved. Pip is convinced the accused boy was innocent, and the book gives her a clear task and a growing pile of evidence. The hook lands at once, and the mystery holds up across 431 pages without a sagging middle. The plotting is tightly built around clues the reader can follow alongside her, so the logic feels earned rather than conjured. It is a standard small-town whodunit setup, and it leans on familiar tropes rather than reinventing them. The characters are solid for a YA mystery, and the book is driven by story rather than ideas. It is the first in a series, though this entry resolves its own case.
At 431 pages it is mid-length for the genre, longer than BookWard's tight preference but it keeps moving.
Each interview and new piece of evidence pushes the case forward, which matches BookWard's fast-moving preference.
The framing is fresh for YA, with the project-as-investigation format, though the core mystery is familiar to genre readers.
The writing is plain and clean, built for momentum, which sits near BookWard's lean-to-middle preference.
The investigation and its reveals drive the book more than internal change, so it leans plot-driven.
It balances a dark crime with a determined, justice-seeking heroine, landing in the middle of the outlook range.
It is a conventional investigation, with project-style framing adding a mild structural twist.
The mood is serious and tense, with only light moments between the teen characters.
The story deals with murder, suicide, abuse and threats, so it goes darker than a typical teen read.
Grief and fear run through the case, but the emotion is kept in check by the puzzle.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 8
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
- Sagging middleBookWard 8 · book 8
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 5
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 4
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 7
At 431 pages it is mid-length for the genre, longer than BookWard's tight preference but it keeps moving.
A murder everyone thinks is solved and a student determined to reopen it gives the book an immediate pull BookWard rewards.
A small-town murder, a teen sleuth and a school-project cover story are well-worn mystery territory, short of BookWard's tropes-averse taste.
The case advances through interviews, evidence and threats Pip can follow, so the investigation holds together well, a little short of airtight.
Each interview and new piece of evidence pushes the case forward, which matches BookWard's fast-moving preference.
The framing is fresh for YA, with the project-as-investigation format, though the core mystery is familiar to genre readers.
Pip is a clearly drawn, driven lead, though supporting characters lean toward suspects and types more than full portraits.
The central murder case is resolved by the end, which BookWard values, even with sequels following.
The tone stays mostly clear-eyed, with some emotional beats around the families touched by the case.
The darkness serves the mystery rather than existing for effect, though some turns are built to jolt.
This is a novel, so this dial does not apply.
Pip's determined, school-project voice and the case-file framing give it a recognizable style without being singular.
This is a story-led mystery driven by the investigation, closer to BookWard's story preference than an idea-led book.
Information comes through interviews and evidence she gathers, with some explaining of the case along the way.
The investigation keeps escalating, so there is little slack through the middle of the book.
The writing is plain and clean, built for momentum, which sits near BookWard's lean-to-middle preference.
The investigation and its reveals drive the book more than internal change, so it leans plot-driven.
It balances a dark crime with a determined, justice-seeking heroine, landing in the middle of the outlook range.
It is a conventional investigation, with project-style framing adding a mild structural twist.
The mood is serious and tense, with only light moments between the teen characters.
Accessible YA prose and a clear investigative thread make this an easy read.
The story follows Pip's investigation as its single central lens.
The story moves forward in the present, with the old case reconstructed through her research.
It is a grounded, realistic crime story with no fantastical elements.
A town of suspects, classmates and family members gives it a moderately sized cast to track.
The stakes are one small town and one case, which keeps the scope intimate.
Interviews, evidence gathering and threats keep the focus on external action over reflection.
Much of the investigation happens in conversation, so interviews carry a lot of the book.
A relationship develops around the investigation but it stays in the background of the case.
The setting is an ordinary English town and school, instantly familiar rather than unfamiliar.
It is set in the present day, which suits BookWard's lean toward contemporary settings.
It is tied to the true-crime moment and a modern teen setting, so it sits closer to its time.
The narration follows Pip straightforwardly, with no reason to doubt what it reports.
The right and wrong of the case are fairly clear, though the culprit's reasons add some gray.
Description is functional, sketching settings quickly to keep the investigation moving.
This is fiction, so the nonfiction style dial does not apply.
This is fiction, so the nonfiction perspective dial does not apply.
It opens a series of three novels and a novella, though this book's case is self-contained.
The mystery is built on revelations and reversals, a mainstay of what the book offers.
It is a gripping page-turner more than a book that unsettles or demands much of its reader.
The story deals with murder, suicide, abuse and threats, so it goes darker than a typical teen read.
Grief and fear run through the case, but the emotion is kept in check by the puzzle.
What humor there is comes through light, dry teen banter rather than broad comedy.
Murder, threats and a dog's death shape the story, with the violence mostly reported rather than lingered on.
Sexual violence is part of the backstory, but the book handles it as plot rather than explicit content.
Politics is largely absent, with the focus on the case and the town.
The language is plain, contemporary and easy to follow.
The narration stays close to Pip and the facts, with little editorializing.
It mostly looks back at a past crime, while the investigation itself moves toward the present.
Pip's belief that the truth matters pushes it toward idealism, tempered by what she uncovers.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is A Good Girl's Guide to Murder right for?
Suited to teens and adult readers of mystery. It deals with murder, suicide, abuse, sexual violence and threats, including a pet's death, so some readers may want to be prepared.
Accessible YA prose and a clear investigative thread make this an easy read.
The story deals with murder, suicide, abuse and threats, so it goes darker than a typical teen read.
Grief and fear run through the case, but the emotion is kept in check by the puzzle.
Murder, threats and a dog's death shape the story, with the violence mostly reported rather than lingered on.
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: ideas, characters, themes
A true crime enthusiast turns a school project into a real investigation of a murder her town believes was solved.
- The project as cover. Pip uses her school project as a reason to dig into the Andie Bell case and question what everyone accepted.
- A case thought closed. Five years earlier, Andie's boyfriend Sal was believed to be the killer, and he died soon after.
- Pip's conviction. She is certain Sal was innocent and that the real culprit is still free.
- An unlikely partner. Sal's brother Ravi first refuses to help, then joins her investigation.
- Rising danger. As she digs, Pip meets threats that make clear someone wants her to stop.
Characters
Pip Fitz-Amobi
Protagonist
A seventeen-year-old true crime fan who investigates the murder for her school project.
Andie Bell
Murder victim
A popular student whose killing sits at the center of the case.
Sal Singh
Accused
Andie's boyfriend, believed to be her killer, whom Pip believes was falsely accused.
Ravi Singh
Ally
Sal's brother, who comes to help Pip with the investigation.
Themes
How a community can settle on an answer that may not be correct.
What it takes to clear a name and find the real culprit.
How an investigation can take over a person's life.
The risks of questioning what others want left buried.
A young person challenging how adults handled a case.
Discussion questions
- Why does Pip believe Sal is innocent when the town does not?
- How does framing the investigation as a school project shape what Pip can do?
- What risks does Pip take, and were they worth it?
- How does the town's long-held version of events affect the people in it?
- What makes a mystery feel fair to the reader as clues appear?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
A podcast-era sequel where a missing person pulls Pip back in
As Good as DeadHolly JacksonPip's last case turns the hunter into the hunted
One of us is nextKaren M. McManusA fast truth-or-dare thriller that brings Bayview High back
Think TwiceHarlan CobenA dead client turns up as a murder suspect
Track A Good Girl's Guide to Murder and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.