Cover of The Mistake by Elle Kennedy
Romance · first published 2015

The Mistake

by Elle Kennedy

★ Top 25 book of 2015 · #17 on Best Books of 2015

A charming hockey star hiding doubts about his future makes a careless error that drives away a college freshman he was drawn to. A year later she is more confident, and he must work hard to earn a second chance.

Best for: College-set romance readers who like second chances and a determined heroine

The Mistake is #17 on BookWard's Best Books of 2015, out of 55 2015 books that cleared our data bar.

Add to my shelf, freeSee all Best Books of 2015

#17on Best Books of 2015
66BookWard year score
772Open Library readers
3.7 ★15 ratings
39reading it now

What The Mistake is about

John Logan is a college junior and a hockey star whose life is a steady run of parties and hook-ups. Beneath the charm, he is quietly worried that the road waiting for him after graduation leads nowhere. A sexy encounter with freshman Grace Ivers might have become something more, until a thoughtless mistake on his part pushes her away.

Grace is back at Briar University, older and wiser after a difficult first year, and she is done with the arrogant player she nearly lost her virginity to. Logan spends his final year trying to prove he deserves a second chance. Grace has her own terms: he will have to work to win her back, and she intends to be in the driver's seat. This new adult romance mixes humor, heat and emotion, with themes of trust, growing up and facing an uncertain future.

The Mistake on the Best Books of 2015

The Mistake came out in 2015. Of the 55 books first published in 2015 that met BookWard's data bar, it ranks #17 on our Best Books of 2015 list.

Why it made the list: 772 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 3.7 out of 5 (15 ratings); 39 are reading it right now. The list ranks each year’s books on how many readers have picked them up, how highly readers rate them, and how many are reading them right now.

Nearby on the 2015 list

See all Best Books of 2015 Best books by year

More years: Best Books of 2014 Best Books of 2016.

The numbers behind it

  • Readers: 701 want to read it, 39 are reading it now and 31 have read it, according to Open Library.
  • Ratings: 3.7 out of 5 from 15 Open Library ratings.
SignalThis book (0 to 100)Weight
Reach8755%
Reader love525%
Being read right now8420%

Questions about The Mistake

When was The Mistake published?

The Mistake by Elle Kennedy was first published in 2015.

Was The Mistake one of the best books of 2015?

The Mistake is #17 on BookWard's Best Books of 2015, out of 55 2015 books that cleared our data bar. 772 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 3.7 out of 5 (15 ratings); 39 are reading it right now.

Why is The Mistake on the Best Books of 2015 list?

772 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 3.7 out of 5 (15 ratings); 39 are reading it right now.

More of the best books of 2015

See the full Best Books of 2015, the Top 100, or new books on Rising.

How we know

This page uses public data: Open Library reader counts and ratings, and Wikipedia page views for recent years. The description is paraphrased from real source text. Rankings reflect reading interest, not quality or sales, and can be affected by data gaps. Lists update monthly.

Who it is for

Suits adult and older-teen readers of romance who are comfortable with college-age characters and open sexual content.

Time to read

Depends on the edition you pick.

BookWard’s verdict

A hockey-romance second chance with a heroine in the driver's seat. 43% taste match

Get it

Where to find it

BookWard’s take

A hockey-romance second chance with a heroine in the driver's seat

The Mistake is a college sports romance built on a familiar engine: a charming hockey player, a girl he wronged, and a year of making amends. It leans hard on well-worn tropes, and it never pretends otherwise. Romance is the whole point here, and the dialogue-forward, banter-driven setup keeps things moving at a good clip. The feeling is warm rather than restrained, and the mood stays hopeful. Where it earns attention is Grace, who returns older and unwilling to be handled, flipping the usual power balance between the leads. Expect a comfort read with real heat, not a book that rewrites the genre.

Read it ifYou want a swoony, banter-heavy college romance where the heroine sets the terms.
Skip it ifYou want fresh plotting or a romance that steers clear of familiar tropes.
Where this book sits on our ten dials
BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
LengthExtreme
Tight and shortLong and sprawling

A standard-length contemporary romance rather than a sprawling saga, which sits fine with BookWard's preference for tight books.

PaceStrong
SlowFast

Banter, parties and push-pull between the leads keep scenes moving at a brisk, readable clip.

OriginalityStrong
FamiliarOriginal

The campus sports romance is a familiar template, with the reversed power dynamic its main variation.

ProseLeaning
PlainOrnate

Plain, conversational prose that stays out of the way of the banter.

DriveLeaning
Plot-drivenCharacter-driven

What happens is driven by who these two are and how they respond to each other.

OutlookLeaning
BleakHopeful

A second chance and a heroine taking control point toward a warm, hopeful outcome.

StructureLeaning
ConventionalExperimental

A conventional linear romance structure, with no formal experiments.

ToneLeaning
SeriousFunny

Flirty banter and charm give it a light, teasing humor alongside the heat.

ContentCentered
GentleDark

Mostly light and flirty, with only some insecurity and regret underneath.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

Heightened attraction, hurt pride and longing give it real emotional pull.

See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book

Where it lines up

  • PaceBookWard 8 · book 7
  • EndingBookWard 8 · book 9
  • ExpositionBookWard 2 · book 3

Where it pulls apart

  • Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 2
  • Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 5
  • LengthBookWard 1 · book 5
BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
Extreme 4 dials
LengthExtreme
Tight and shortLong and sprawling

A standard-length contemporary romance rather than a sprawling saga, which sits fine with BookWard's preference for tight books.

OpeningExtreme
Slow buildHooks at once

The setup of a past hookup and a thoughtless mistake gives it a ready-made tension, though it is not a cold-open grabber.

Familiar tropesExtreme
Leans on tropesAvoids them

Hockey star, jaded charm and a second-chance grovel are well-worn romance tropes, which cuts against BookWard's taste for avoiding them.

Internal logicExtreme
LooseAirtight

Romance logic runs on character choices and timing, coherent enough but not built to be airtight.

Strong 11 dials
PaceStrong
SlowFast

Banter, parties and push-pull between the leads keep scenes moving at a brisk, readable clip.

OriginalityStrong
FamiliarOriginal

The campus sports romance is a familiar template, with the reversed power dynamic its main variation.

Character depthStrong
TypesDeeply drawn

Logan's hidden despair about his future and Grace's growth give the leads some shading beyond types.

EndingStrong
Open, ambiguousFully resolved

Romance conventions point to a satisfying, resolved payoff, which BookWard tends to like.

SentimentStrong
SentimentalRestrained

Genre romance leans into feeling and wish fulfillment, more sentimental than BookWard's restrained taste.

Shock for effectStrong
Leans on shockEarns its darkness

Its drama comes from relationship missteps rather than shock for effect, so little is cheaply dark.

Rigor (nonfiction)Not applicableStrong
AnecdotalRigorous

Not applicable to a work of fiction.

Authorial voiceStrong
GenericDistinctive

Playful, confident romance narration with attitude, distinctive enough within its genre.

Story or ideasStrong
Story-ledIdea-led

This is story and relationship first, with no thesis driving it.

ExpositionStrong
Shown in sceneExplained outright

Emotional backstory is mostly carried by scene and dialogue rather than lectures.

Sagging middleStrong
Sags in the middleSustained throughout

A year-long second-chance arc can wander, but the push-pull between the leads gives it steady momentum.

Leaning 25 dials
ProseLeaning
PlainOrnate

Plain, conversational prose that stays out of the way of the banter.

DriveLeaning
Plot-drivenCharacter-driven

What happens is driven by who these two are and how they respond to each other.

OutlookLeaning
BleakHopeful

A second chance and a heroine taking control point toward a warm, hopeful outcome.

StructureLeaning
ConventionalExperimental

A conventional linear romance structure, with no formal experiments.

ToneLeaning
SeriousFunny

Flirty banter and charm give it a light, teasing humor alongside the heat.

Reading effortLeaning
EasyDemanding

An easy, quick read that asks little effort of the reader.

ViewpointsLeaning
SingleMany

Romances like this typically alternate between the two leads, which gives it a modest spread of viewpoints.

TimelineLeaning
LinearShifting

A chronological second-chance story that moves forward through the school year.

RealityLeaning
GroundedFantastical

Fully grounded in contemporary college life.

Cast sizeLeaning
SmallLarge

A campus ensemble of teammates and friends surrounds the central pair, but the focus stays tight.

ScaleLeaning
IntimateEpic

An intimate story about two people and their relationship.

FocusLeaning
Inner thoughtsOuter action

Feelings, attraction and self-doubt drive it more than external action.

DialogueLeaning
LightHeavy

Banter and verbal sparring between the leads carry much of the book.

RomanceLeaning
MinorCentral

The central relationship is the whole point of the book.

SettingLeaning
FamiliarUnfamiliar

A familiar college campus and hockey culture, easy to step into.

EraLeaning
PastPresent day

A present-day campus setting with modern dating culture.

Staying powerLeaning
Of its momentTimeless

Firmly tied to a contemporary new-adult moment, though the second-chance pattern is perennial.

NarratorLeaning
ReliableUnreliable

Narration is straightforward about what the leads feel and want.

Moral clarityLeaning
ClearAmbiguous

The right and wrong of Logan's mistake and Grace's response are fairly clear-cut.

DescriptionLeaning
SparseRich

Description is light, in service of mood and attraction rather than place.

Nonfiction styleNot applicableLeaning
NarrativeAnalytical

Not applicable to a work of fiction.

PerspectiveLeaning
PersonalDetached

Close, intimate perspective on the leads' thoughts and wants.

SeriesLeaning
StandalonePart of a series

Part of the Off-Campus series, so it sits inside a larger run rather than standing alone.

SurprisesLeaning
FewMany

Second-chance romance follows a predictable arc, so surprises are few.

Comfort or challengeLeaning
ComfortingChallenging

A comforting, familiar read that rarely pushes the reader.

Centered 10 dials
ContentCentered
GentleDark

Mostly light and flirty, with only some insecurity and regret underneath.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

Heightened attraction, hurt pride and longing give it real emotional pull.

Humor styleCentered
DryBroad

Playful, teasing banter rather than dry understatement.

Violence on the pageCentered
LittleA lot
Sexual contentCentered
LittleA lot

Heat and hookups are central to the story, so sexual content is prominent.

PoliticsCentered
AbsentFront and center

Campus romance with no political angle.

Language difficultyCentered
PlainDialect or dense

Plain, contemporary American language throughout.

NarrationCentered
NeutralOpinionated

Voice-forward and attitude-heavy narration that picks sides with its leads.

LooksCentered
BackForward

Looks ahead to graduation and what comes next for both leads.

WorldviewCentered
CynicalIdealistic

Believes people can earn forgiveness and a second chance, an idealistic streak.

Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.

Age and content

Who is The Mistake right for?

Suits adult and older-teen readers of romance who are comfortable with college-age characters and open sexual content. Contains frank sexual situations and hookup culture.

BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
Reading effortLeaning
EasyDemanding

An easy, quick read that asks little effort of the reader.

ContentCentered
GentleDark

Mostly light and flirty, with only some insecurity and regret underneath.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

Heightened attraction, hurt pride and longing give it real emotional pull.

Violence on the pageCentered
LittleA lot
Book Companion

The Mistake: ideas, characters, themes

A hockey star who hurt a girl by accident spends his final year trying to win her trust back, while she decides how much to give.

  • The setup. Logan and Grace share a charged encounter freshman year that ends badly because of a thoughtless mistake.
  • Roles reversed. Grace returns older and more confident, no longer the quiet girl who nearly gave up her virginity to him.
  • Earning it. Logan has to work for a second chance rather than relying on his usual charm.
  • Hidden worry. Behind his easygoing front, Logan is anxious about the dead-end path waiting after graduation.
  • Campus backdrop. The story plays out at Briar University among hockey teammates, parties and hookups.

Characters

John Logan

Hockey star and love interest

A college junior with easy charm and a string of hookups who privately dreads life after graduation.

Grace Ivers

Heroine

A former freshman who returns wiser and more assertive, determined to be in control this time.

Themes

Second chances

Whether a real mistake can be undone through effort and change.

Power and control

Who holds the upper hand in a relationship and how that shifts.

Growing up

How a year of experience changes what each lead wants and tolerates.

Image versus self

The gap between Logan's carefree persona and his private fears.

Discussion questions

  1. Does Logan earn a second chance, and what would convince you?
  2. How does Grace taking control change the usual dynamic of this kind of romance?
  3. What does Logan's worry about life after graduation add to his character?
  4. Which familiar romance tropes does the book use, and which does it twist?
  5. Is Grace right to make him work for it?
Made for you

Personalize your Book Companion

This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.

Personalize your Companion, free

Where to get it

Buy, listen or borrow The Mistake

Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.

Find your own best books

Add what you have read, rate it, and BookWard will recommend what to read next.

Free to start. No credit card needed.