It suits older teens and adults who enjoy young adult romance, retellings and heist stories.
391 pages, about 6 to 9 hours.
A heist, a gilded cage, and a myth retold with a queer love story. 56% taste match
The story
Icarus is a young adult romance by Kayla Ancrum, first published in 2024. It is a contemporary fantasy that retells a myth, with a queer love story at its center, and it runs about 391 pages.
The story follows Icarus Gallagher, a teenager who lifts valuable paintings and leaves forged copies in their place, working alongside his father, Angus Gallagher. Their target is the wealthy Mr. Black, whom they blame for the death of Icarus's mother. Icarus keeps himself guarded with a short list of personal rules meant to keep others at a distance. Everything changes when he is caught by Helios Black, Mr. Black's son, who lives under house arrest in the family mansion. Rather than expose him, Helios proposes a friendship. As the two grow closer, Icarus begins to see how both of their families have been confined for years, and he must weigh his father's hunger for revenge against his own wish to get free. The book is set in Illinois.
It was dark in this house.
Characters
Icarus GallagherHelios BlackAngus Gallagher
Setting
Illinois
Themes
RomanceYoung AdultQueerLGBTContemporaryMythologyRetellingsFantasy
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 391 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 7.2 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 3 editions from 2 publishers, the earliest dated 2024 and the latest 2025.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 48% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Dewey [Fic] and Library of Congress class PZ-0007.10000000.A53 Ic 2024.
A heist, a gilded cage, and a myth retold with a queer love story
Icarus takes the old myth and turns it into a contemporary heist romance, which gives it a ready hook: a teenage art thief with a list of rules for keeping people away, caught on his own turf. At about 391 pages it runs a little long for my taste, but the setup promises forward motion, and I'm fond of a strong opening and steady pace. The love story is what drives the book, so expect romance to sit at the center, and the mythological retelling gives it a fantastical edge. The open question is how much it leans on familiar tropes: the guarded hero, the forbidden closeness, the vengeful family. The premise is fresh enough, though, that the retelling angle should keep it from feeling stock.
At 391 pages it is a full-length novel, longer than BookWard's taste for tight books, though a heist premise can carry the extra pages.
Art thefts, a risky bargain and a father pushing for revenge suggest a story that keeps moving, close to what BookWard likes.
Retelling Icarus as a contemporary art-forgery romance is a distinctive angle, though the romance beats themselves are well worn.
Young adult contemporary fantasy tends toward accessible, readable prose rather than ornate language.
The central question is who Icarus becomes through his bond with Helios, so character carries the book more than the heist.
A story about two trapped boys finding each other and weighing escape leans hopeful, with real grief underneath.
A single-protagonist retelling with a conventional arc suggests a standard structure rather than an experimental one.
The setup is serious in tone, built on grief, revenge and confinement, with room for the lightness a friendship brings.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 7
- Character depthBookWard 8 · book 7
Where it pulls apart
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 6
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 5
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
At 391 pages it is a full-length novel, longer than BookWard's taste for tight books, though a heist premise can carry the extra pages.
A thief caught mid-job by a mysterious boy under house arrest is a strong opening situation, right in line with BookWard's taste.
Guarded hero, forbidden closeness and a family bent on revenge are familiar shapes, though the myth retelling gives them a new frame.
A heist built on forgeries and personal rules implies a system with working mechanics, though the mythic layer leaves some room for looseness.
Art thefts, a risky bargain and a father pushing for revenge suggest a story that keeps moving, close to what BookWard likes.
Retelling Icarus as a contemporary art-forgery romance is a distinctive angle, though the romance beats themselves are well worn.
Icarus's rules for keeping people away give him a clear inner shape, and the romance is built on how those rules break down.
His final choice between escape and the boy he loves points toward a decided outcome, which fits BookWard's liking for resolution.
A young adult love story built on closeness and loss leans warm and emotional, a little more sentimental than BookWard prefers.
The darkness here comes from grief and revenge rooted in a mother's death, which reads as earned rather than shock for its own sake.
This is a novel, so rigor does not apply.
Kayla Ancrum's mix of heist, myth and romance suggests a recognizable authorial hand, though the voice is not the book's main draw.
The book is story-led, driven by the heist, the romance and the family conflict rather than by an argument.
Icarus's rules and the family backstory are likely handed to the reader early, but the plot mostly plays out in scene.
A romance-and-revenge plot with a ticking family conflict has reasons to keep tension up, though 391 pages invite some slack.
Young adult contemporary fantasy tends toward accessible, readable prose rather than ornate language.
The central question is who Icarus becomes through his bond with Helios, so character carries the book more than the heist.
A story about two trapped boys finding each other and weighing escape leans hopeful, with real grief underneath.
A single-protagonist retelling with a conventional arc suggests a standard structure rather than an experimental one.
The setup is serious in tone, built on grief, revenge and confinement, with room for the lightness a friendship brings.
A young adult novel with a clear premise and a focused cast is an easy read, not a demanding one.
The retelling and fantasy label add a mythic layer, but the heist and mansion setting stay rooted in the contemporary world.
The story turns on Icarus, Helios, Angus and Mr. Black, a small circle that keeps the cast tight.
A house, a father and son, and one other family keep the story intimate despite the mythic frame.
Thefts and a standoff provide action, while Icarus's guarded interior drives the emotional story; the two balance out.
A friendship and romance that grow through bargaining and closeness lean on conversation between the two boys.
The love between Icarus and Helios is the engine of the story, which makes romance central rather than a side plot.
Illinois and a wealthy family's mansion are ordinary, recognizable settings rather than unfamiliar worlds.
The book is a contemporary story set in the present day.
The myth underneath is ancient, but a contemporary young adult romance is likelier to feel tied to its moment.
Stealing to avenge a death makes the ethics muddy, though the push toward escape and love gives a clear emotional direction.
A gilded mansion and a world of fine art invite visual detail, without suggesting the book is mainly descriptive.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Icarus right for?
It suits older teens and adults who enjoy young adult romance, retellings and heist stories. It deals with grief over a parent's death, family conflict and a romance between two boys.
A young adult novel with a clear premise and a focused cast is an easy read, not a demanding one.
Icarus: ideas, characters, themes
A teenage art thief who keeps everyone at arm's length is caught by the one person who offers him a way out.
- A thief with rules. Icarus steals paintings and swaps in forgeries made by his father, following strict rules meant to keep people and feelings away.
- A long grudge. The family targets the wealthy Mr. Black, whom they blame for the death of Icarus's mother.
- An unexpected catch. Icarus is caught by Helios, Mr. Black's son, who lives under house arrest in the family mansion.
- A dangerous bargain. Instead of turning Icarus in, Helios proposes a friendship, which breaks the rules Icarus has lived by.
- Two families, one cage. As the boys grow closer, Icarus sees how both families have been confined, and has to weigh escape against his father's thirst for revenge.
Characters
Icarus Gallagher
Protagonist
A teenage thief who guards himself with strict personal rules and wants to escape the life his family is stuck in.
Helios Black
Love interest
Mr. Black's son, held under house arrest in the family mansion, who catches Icarus and offers friendship instead of exposure.
Angus Gallagher
Icarus's father
The forger behind the copies Icarus leaves in place of stolen art, driven by a lasting wish for revenge.
Mr. Black
Antagonist
A wealthy man the Gallaghers blame for the death of Icarus's mother and have targeted for years.
Themes
How a grudge can hold a family in place, and what it costs to let go.
Icarus's rules keep people out, and the story tests what happens when someone gets in anyway.
Both boys live inside conflicts their parents started.
The Icarus story reworked in a modern setting, with reaching too high and falling as a live question.
Choosing another person means giving up some control and some safety.
Discussion questions
- Why does Icarus build rules to keep people away, and what do those rules protect him from?
- How does retelling the Icarus myth in a contemporary heist change what flying too close to the sun means?
- In what ways are the Gallagher and Black families both trapped?
- Is Icarus's choice between escape and love a fair one, or does his father's revenge make it unfair?
- What does Helios offer Icarus that no one else in his life has?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Icarus
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Icarus
A romance with a ghost-story twist, built on a bed-and-breakfast stay
All the Bright PlacesJennifer NivenTwo teenagers meet on a ledge and change each other
TearsmithErin DoomA dark orphanage romance built on shared trauma and a made-up monster
I Fell in Love with HopeLancaliA hospital heist, a found family, and a girl with sun eyes
Sources: Open Library.
Track Icarus and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.