
Aimed at older teens and young adults who enjoy emotionally intense romance.
576 pages, about 9 to 13.5 hours.
A dark orphanage romance built on shared trauma and a made-up monster. 45% taste match
The story
Tearsmith is a romance novel by Erin Doom, first published in 2024. It follows Nica, who spent her childhood in an orphanage run by a cruel matron. To endure it, she withdrew into invented stories, among them tales of the Tearsmith, a figure said to make tears and to forge the fears that live inside people. At seventeen she is adopted and believes those years are finally behind her.
Her new household changes when Rigel, a young man who grew up in the same orphanage from infancy, arrives to join the family. He and Nica share a history marked by mistrust and hostility, and living under one roof again draws them toward one another despite everything between them. The novel centers on a love shaped by the pain they both survived, and on what they must confront from their past before any relationship between them can take hold. It runs to roughly 576 pages and is aimed at readers drawn to dark, emotionally charged young adult romance, with a pair of leads who are bound together by shared trauma as much as by attraction.
- Want to read 189
- Reading now 8
- Read 9
Most people shelving it are saving it for later.
Of 206 readers who put it on a shelf, 92% want to read it, 4% are reading it now, 4% have finished it and 0% stopped before the end.
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 576 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 11 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 2 editions from 2 publishers.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 2% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Library of Congress class PQ-4904.00000000.
A dark orphanage romance built on shared trauma and a made-up monster
Tearsmith is a 576-page young adult romance that pairs a fairy-tale frame with a hostile-to-lovers setup. The Tearsmith myth gives it a fantastical streak, and the orphanage past gives it real weight. That is where it earns its keep, with strong character depth and plenty of emotion. It is also a long book, longer than I'd usually choose, and the romance is front and center, so the story leans on feeling more than ideas. The likelier trouble is familiarity: forbidden love, a brooding lead and a shared wound are well-worn ground, and I'm least likely to be convinced on cliche and originality. If the premise hooks you, the opening has an edge.
At 576 pages it is a long read for a romance, well past the tight end BookWard prefers.
A long romance built on emotional beats tends to move at a measured, steady pace.
The Tearsmith myth adds a distinct touch, but the central romance follows well-known patterns.
Fairy-tale imagery and emotional intensity suggest prose with some lyrical lift.
The story hinges on how two damaged people relate to each other, so character drives the plot.
A love story that has to push past trauma carries a hopeful pull beneath its dark past.
A conventional romance arc, lightly colored by the story-within-a-story of the Tearsmith.
A dark, emotionally charged romance with little room for humor.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- Character depthBookWard 8 · book 7
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 7
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 2
Where it pulls apart
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 9
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 3
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 5
At 576 pages it is a long read for a romance, well past the tight end BookWard prefers.
The orphanage and the Tearsmith legend give it an immediate premise, though a slow-burn romance may not grip at once.
Forbidden love, a troubled brooding lead and shared trauma are familiar romance tropes, which cuts against BookWard's taste.
A romance driven by feeling and a fairy-tale frame, so internal logic is not its main concern.
A long romance built on emotional beats tends to move at a measured, steady pace.
The Tearsmith myth adds a distinct touch, but the central romance follows well-known patterns.
Both leads are shaped by the same abusive upbringing, which gives their conflict real psychological grounding.
Intense, yearning romance leans sentimental rather than restrained, a mismatch with BookWard.
Darkness comes from the orphanage past and is part of the premise, though some of it may be there for effect.
Fiction, so this dial does not apply.
The fairy-tale framing gives it some flavor, though the romance voice is fairly genre-standard.
Heavily story and relationship-led, with feeling driving it more than ideas.
Backstory about the orphanage and its myth is likely to be woven into scenes and memory rather than lectured.
At this length, romance plots with a long slow burn can drift in the middle.
Fairy-tale imagery and emotional intensity suggest prose with some lyrical lift.
The story hinges on how two damaged people relate to each other, so character drives the plot.
A love story that has to push past trauma carries a hopeful pull beneath its dark past.
A conventional romance arc, lightly colored by the story-within-a-story of the Tearsmith.
A dark, emotionally charged romance with little room for humor.
Accessible young adult romance that reads easily despite its length.
The orphanage past shapes the present, but the story moves forward from adoption.
The Tearsmith is a fantastical frame, but the central world is a realistic household.
Centers on Nica, Rigel and their new family, a small circle.
An intimate story about two people and one household.
Focused on feelings, fears and relationships rather than outward action.
Charged exchanges between two hostile leads give dialogue real weight in a romance this long.
Romance is the whole point of the book, with the love story at the center.
A contemporary family home and an orphanage are familiar settings, with a fantasy overlay.
A contemporary young adult story, published in 2024.
Rooted in the trends of dark young adult romance, so it reads as of its moment.
Trauma, hostility and forbidden love invite some gray areas, but the leads are clearly the heroes.
Atmospheric orphanage settings and the Tearsmith legend call for vivid imagery.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Tearsmith right for?
Aimed at older teens and young adults who enjoy emotionally intense romance. It deals with childhood abuse and trauma and is marketed as dark and sexy, so it suits mature readers.
Accessible young adult romance that reads easily despite its length.
Tearsmith: ideas, characters, themes
Two young people raised in the same cruel orphanage are drawn together by shared trauma and have to face their past before love can be real.
- A cruel start. Nica grows up in an orphanage run by an abusive matron, which shapes how she sees the world.
- Escape through stories. She copes by retreating into imagination, especially tales of the Tearsmith, who forges fears.
- A new family. At seventeen she is adopted and believes her old life is behind her.
- Rigel arrives. A young man from the same orphanage joins her new household, bringing the past with him.
- Love and trauma. Their mistrust gives way to attraction, but the past must be faced before anything can last.
Characters
Nica
Protagonist
A young woman adopted at seventeen who copes with her past through imagination and stories.
Rigel
Love interest
A troubled, striking young man raised from birth in the same orphanage, who joins Nica's new family.
The Tearsmith
Legend
A figure from Nica's invented tales who makes tears and forges the fears people carry.
Themes
How a painful past can bind two people together as strongly as attraction does.
Using stories to survive circumstances that cannot be changed.
A relationship complicated by family ties and history.
The need to confront old pain before a future can begin.
Discussion questions
- Why does Nica turn to stories to cope, and what does the Tearsmith represent for her?
- How does shared trauma shape the way Nica and Rigel relate to each other?
- Does the fairy-tale frame deepen the romance or distract from it?
- What makes a hostile-to-lovers relationship believable, and does this one succeed?
- Should the past be faced before love can begin, or can love help in facing it?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Tearsmith
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Tearsmith
A heist, a gilded cage, and a myth retold with a queer love story
Twisted LiesAna HuangA steamy, dark fake-dating romance built on obsession and secrets
LaylaColleen HooverA romance with a ghost-story twist, built on a bed-and-breakfast stay
ConfessColleen HooverA secrets-driven Dallas romance that favors feeling over surprise
Sources: Open Library.
Track Tearsmith and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.