Historical Fiction464 pages, 7 to 10.5 hours

When the Tides Held the Moon

by Venessa Vida Kelley · 2025

Add to my shelf, free

Who it is for

Written for adult readers, it suits those who enjoy historical fantasy and queer romance.

Time to read

464 pages, about 7.5 to 11 hours.

BookWard’s verdict

A captive merman, a Boricua blacksmith, and Coney Island's gilded cage. 55% taste match

Get it

Where to find it

The story

When the Tides Held the Moon is a 2025 historical romantasy by Venessa Vida Kelley, written for adult readers. It blends fantasy, romance, and historical fiction, and it centers on a queer love story with a mermaid element at its heart. The novel runs about 464 pages.

The story takes place in New York City in the 1910s, with much of the action set at Coney Island. Its protagonist is Benigno "Benny" Caldera, an orphaned Boricua blacksmith whose ironwork leads him into the world of a sideshow at Luna Park. There he joins a company of performers and meets Río, a merman held in captivity. Their bond begins out of circumstance and grows into something deeper, and Benny must weigh what he stands to lose against what he owes the one he loves. Found family, belonging, and the cost of freedom run through his choices as he decides what to do about Río's confinement.

Characters

Benigno “Benny” Caldera

Setting

Coney Island (New York, N.Y.)

Themes

FantasyRomanceLGBTQueerHistoricalRomantasyLGBTQ+Adult

By the numbers

  • The median edition runs 464 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 8.5 hours of reading.
  • On reader demand it ranks in the top 63% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
  • Libraries shelve it under Dewey 813.0000 and Library of Congress class PS-3611.00000000.E45 .W44.
BookWard’s take

A captive merman, a Boricua blacksmith, and Coney Island's gilded cage

Venessa Vida Kelley sets this romantasy in 1910s Coney Island, where an orphaned Boricua blacksmith builds an ironwork tank for a Luna Park sideshow and learns what it is meant to hold. The premise hooks at once: a stolen merman, a commissioned cage, a maker complicit before he understands. That opening is a strong fit for me. The familiar tropes are where it gets interesting, since mermaid romance and found family are well-worn, but the period setting and the maker-as-jailer angle give them an edge. At 464 pages, it runs longer than I'd like, and the romance sits at the center rather than the margins. Internal logic and character depth matter most here, because the love story only works if Benny's choice costs him something real.

Read it ifYou want a queer historical romantasy with a vivid sideshow setting and a love story that pushes a character to choose between safety and doing right.
Skip it ifYou prefer shorter books, or want romance kept as a minor thread rather than the main event.
Where this book sits on our ten dials
BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
LengthExtreme
Tight and shortLong and sprawling
PaceStrong
SlowFast

A novel this size carries a steady build rather than a sprint, with a romance that deepens over time.

OriginalityStrong
FamiliarOriginal

A queer merman romance in 1910s Coney Island, told through a Boricua blacksmith, is a distinctive pairing of setting and perspective.

ProseLeaning
PlainOrnate

Romantasy and period atmosphere lean toward lush, evocative writing without tipping into ornate.

DriveLeaning
Plot-drivenCharacter-driven

The central question is what Benny will risk for Río, so the story runs on his choices and feelings.

OutlookLeaning
BleakHopeful

Found family and a love strong enough to free two people point toward an optimistic outlook.

StructureLeaning
ConventionalExperimental

The premise suggests a conventional forward-moving structure built around one central relationship.

ToneLeaning
SeriousFunny

The premise is earnest and emotional, with the sideshow cast allowing only occasional lightness.

ContentCentered
GentleDark

Captivity and exploitation add shadow, but love and found family keep it from turning grim.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

A love story with high stakes and a choice that could cost Benny everything runs warm and intense.

See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book

Where it lines up

  • Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
  • OpeningBookWard 10 · book 9
  • Character depthBookWard 8 · book 7

Where it pulls apart

  • LengthBookWard 1 · book 6
  • Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 5
  • Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
Extreme 4 dials
LengthExtreme
Tight and shortLong and sprawling
OpeningExtreme
Slow buildHooks at once

A blacksmith's commission that turns out to be a cage for a stolen merman gives it an immediate pull.

Familiar tropesExtreme
Leans on tropesAvoids them

Mermaid romance and found family are familiar territory, though the Luna Park setting and the maker-as-jailer angle freshen them.

Internal logicExtreme
LooseAirtight

The sideshow's secret and Benny's role in it set up clear stakes, and the fantasy element is grounded in a real place.

Strong 11 dials
PaceStrong
SlowFast

A novel this size carries a steady build rather than a sprint, with a romance that deepens over time.

OriginalityStrong
FamiliarOriginal

A queer merman romance in 1910s Coney Island, told through a Boricua blacksmith, is a distinctive pairing of setting and perspective.

Character depthStrong
TypesDeeply drawn

Benny's orphaned background and divided loyalties give him real interior stakes, and the sideshow company offers room for a lived-in cast.

EndingStrong
Open, ambiguousFully resolved
SentimentStrong
SentimentalRestrained

Love, found family and freedom invite warmth, so it likely feels more heartfelt than restrained.

Shock for effectStrong
Leans on shockEarns its darkness

The darkness here comes from captivity and its moral weight, which suits BookWard's preference for darkness that is earned.

Rigor (nonfiction)Not applicableStrong
AnecdotalRigorous

This is a novel, so the dial does not apply.

Authorial voiceStrong
GenericDistinctive

A fresh point of view and setting give it a distinct footing, though the voice stays within romantasy conventions.

Story or ideasStrong
Story-ledIdea-led

This is a story-led novel built around a love affair and a rescue, not an argument.

ExpositionStrong
Shown in sceneExplained outright

The sideshow's secret and the historical setting call for some explaining, balanced by scene-driven romance.

Sagging middleStrong
Sags in the middleSustained throughout

A long romance has to keep Benny's dilemma tightening, and the captivity thread supplies steady tension.

Leaning 25 dials
ProseLeaning
PlainOrnate

Romantasy and period atmosphere lean toward lush, evocative writing without tipping into ornate.

DriveLeaning
Plot-drivenCharacter-driven

The central question is what Benny will risk for Río, so the story runs on his choices and feelings.

OutlookLeaning
BleakHopeful

Found family and a love strong enough to free two people point toward an optimistic outlook.

StructureLeaning
ConventionalExperimental

The premise suggests a conventional forward-moving structure built around one central relationship.

ToneLeaning
SeriousFunny

The premise is earnest and emotional, with the sideshow cast allowing only occasional lightness.

Reading effortLeaning
EasyDemanding

Accessible romantasy that reads smoothly despite its length and historical backdrop.

ViewpointsLeaning
SingleMany
TimelineLeaning
LinearShifting
RealityLeaning
GroundedFantastical

A live merman is the heart of the book, set against an otherwise real New York.

Cast sizeLeaning
SmallLarge

A sideshow company of performers gives it a mid-sized ensemble around the central pair.

ScaleLeaning
IntimateEpic

The story stays close to one relationship and one place, so it feels intimate rather than epic.

FocusLeaning
Inner thoughtsOuter action

Benny's moral reckoning and the sideshow's plot pull in balance, with feeling given equal weight.

DialogueLeaning
LightHeavy

A romance among a close-knit company leans on conversation to build bonds.

RomanceLeaning
MinorCentral

The love between Benny and Río is the central engine of the book.

SettingLeaning
FamiliarUnfamiliar

Luna Park's sideshow world and Coney Island make the setting vivid and unfamiliar to most readers.

EraLeaning
PastPresent day

The story is set in the 1910s, firmly in the past.

Staying powerLeaning
Of its momentTimeless

Love, belonging and the cost of freedom are lasting themes, though the genre packaging is of its time.

NarratorLeaning
ReliableUnreliable

Nothing suggests a narrator who misleads, so the telling reads as straightforward.

Moral clarityLeaning
ClearAmbiguous

Keeping a being in a cage is clearly wrong, though Benny's tangled loyalties add nuance.

DescriptionLeaning
SparseRich

A historical fantasy depends on atmosphere, from ironwork to Luna Park's spectacle.

Nonfiction styleNot applicableLeaning
NarrativeAnalytical

This is fiction, so the dial does not apply.

PerspectiveNot applicableLeaning
PersonalDetached

This is fiction, so the dial does not apply.

SeriesLeaning
StandalonePart of a series

Nothing indicates it is part of a series.

SurprisesLeaning
FewMany

A secret at the sideshow's core and a captive's fate leave room for some turns.

Comfort or challengeLeaning
ComfortingChallenging

A love story with a hopeful arc is more comforting than confrontational, though captivity adds weight.

Centered 10 dials
ContentCentered
GentleDark

Captivity and exploitation add shadow, but love and found family keep it from turning grim.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

A love story with high stakes and a choice that could cost Benny everything runs warm and intense.

Humor styleCentered
DryBroad

Humor is not the focus, and what lightness there is leans gentle.

Violence on the pageCentered
LittleA lot
Sexual contentCentered
LittleA lot
PoliticsCentered
AbsentFront and center

Boricua identity and exploitation sit in the background without dominating the story.

Language difficultyCentered
PlainDialect or dense

A period setting may bring some flavor in speech, but the read stays easy.

NarrationCentered
NeutralOpinionated

The story sides firmly with Río's freedom, giving the telling a clear point of view.

LooksCentered
BackForward

It looks back to the 1910s while pushing toward a future of freedom for its characters.

WorldviewCentered
CynicalIdealistic

Love strong enough to free two people is an idealistic premise.

Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.

Age and content

Who is When the Tides Held the Moon right for?

Written for adult readers, it suits those who enjoy historical fantasy and queer romance. It deals with captivity and exploitation and includes adult romantic content.

BookWard’s tasteThis book1 to 10 scale
Reading effortLeaning
EasyDemanding

Accessible romantasy that reads smoothly despite its length and historical backdrop.

ContentCentered
GentleDark

Captivity and exploitation add shadow, but love and found family keep it from turning grim.

EmotionCentered
RestrainedIntense

A love story with high stakes and a choice that could cost Benny everything runs warm and intense.

Violence on the pageCentered
LittleA lot
Book Companion

When the Tides Held the Moon: ideas, characters, themes

A blacksmith who builds a cage for a sideshow must decide what he owes the merman held inside it.

  • The commission. Benny's ironwork tank for Luna Park astounds a sideshow proprietor, who invites him into the show's cast.
  • The secret. The tank is built to hold a live merman taken from the East River.
  • Friendship to love. Benny and Río begin as acquaintances of necessity and grow into something deeper.
  • The cost of freedom. Releasing Río could cost Benny his found family and his home.
  • A choice that frees. Benny's decision about Río's captivity could free them both.

Characters

Benigno "Benny" Caldera

Protagonist

An orphaned Boricua blacksmith in 1910s New York whose ironwork draws him into the sideshow.

Río

The merman

A captive merman who becomes Benny's kindred spirit and the center of his dilemma.

Themes

Captivity and freedom

What it takes to free someone, and what the one who frees them stands to lose.

Found family

The belonging Benny finds among the sideshow performers and what it costs to risk it.

Complicity

Benny's craft built the cage, which forces him to face his own part in it.

Identity and belonging

An orphaned Boricua artist finds a place in a world that doubts his worth.

Love across worlds

A bond between two beings from different lives and what it demands.

Discussion questions

  1. Benny built the tank before he understood its purpose. How responsible is he for what it holds?
  2. What does the sideshow offer Benny that the rest of New York does not?
  3. Why might the story pair a Boricua blacksmith with a merman as kindred spirits?
  4. How does the Coney Island setting shape the way captivity is shown?
  5. What would you risk losing to do what Benny must decide?
Made for you

Personalize your Book Companion

This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.

Personalize your Companion, free

Where to get it

Buy, listen or borrow When the Tides Held the Moon

Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.

Sources: Open Library.

Track When the Tides Held the Moon and find your next favorite

Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.

Free to start. No credit card needed.