
Problematic Summer Romance
by Ali Hazelwood · 2025
Best suited to adult readers of contemporary romance.
402 pages, about 6.5 to 9.5 hours.
A Sicilian wedding week where a forbidden crush finally has nowhere to hide. 51% taste match
The story
Problematic Summer Romance is a contemporary adult romance by Ali Hazelwood, first published in 2025 and running about 402 pages. It sits in the friends-to-lovers tradition and is set over a summer in Italy, with much of the story unfolding in Taormina, on Sicily's Ionian coast.
Maya Killgore is twenty-three, a graduate student still working out what she wants from life. Conor Harkness is thirty-eight, a biotech professional and the best friend of her brother, Eli Killgore. Maya has long had feelings for him, and the gap in their ages and circumstances is a fact both of them are well aware of. When Eli plans a destination wedding in Taormina, Maya and Conor find themselves sharing a villa for more than a week, surrounded by ancient ruins, seaside caves, and plenty of good food. As the wedding preparations grow chaotic, the two are thrown into close company, and Maya begins to suspect Conor is keeping something from her.
The book follows the author's earlier novel Deep End and is aimed at readers of contemporary romance who enjoy warm-weather settings and a slow shift from friendship to something more.
Characters
Eli KillgoreMaya KillgoreConor Harkness
Setting
Taormina (Italy)
Themes
RomanceContemporarySummerContemporary RomanceAdult
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 402 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 7.4 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 3 editions from 3 publishers, across 2 languages.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 8% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
A Sicilian wedding week where a forbidden crush finally has nowhere to hide
Hazelwood builds this one on a very familiar setup: a brother's best friend, an age gap, and a villa in Taormina shared for more than a week. The blurb promises that clichés will turn into plot twists, and that promise is worth testing, since I tend to be hard on books that lean on well-worn tropes. Expect a fast, easy ride rather than a demanding one. The romance sits squarely at the center, and the setting does real work through ruins, caves and food. At 402 pages it's a moderate length, and a wedding spiraling out of control gives the pacing something to chew on. Maya's suspicion that Conor is keeping something from her supplies a bit of mystery. A comfort read with some self-awareness, though not a natural fit for my fondness for airtight, trope-avoiding fiction.
At about 402 pages it is mid-sized for a contemporary romance, longer than BookWard's taste for tight books.
A chaotic wedding and a shared villa keep things moving at a brisk, readable clip, close to BookWard's pace.
The blurb leans into cliché while promising a twist, but the core setup is familiar territory, below BookWard's high bar.
Romance of this kind favors accessible, conversational prose over ornament, plainer than BookWard's middle position.
The story hinges on Maya and Conor's feelings and secrets, so character drives it more than plot machinery.
A summer romance with a promised fling points toward warmth and a happy outlook, above BookWard's.
Banter and a wedding gone sideways suggest a lighter, humorous tone that lands near BookWard's taste.
A warm summer romance keeps its content gentle, lighter than BookWard's middle.
Longing and a fraught crush make the feelings strong, near BookWard's intensity.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 7
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 9
- Shock for effectBookWard 9 · book 8
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 3
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 5
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
At about 402 pages it is mid-sized for a contemporary romance, longer than BookWard's taste for tight books.
A forbidden crush and a looming wedding give it a ready-made pull from the start, close to BookWard's preference.
Older man, younger woman, brother's best friend: the premise is built from well-worn romance tropes, far from BookWard's trope-averse taste.
A contained wedding-week setup keeps events coherent, though romance conventions bend plausibility somewhat.
A chaotic wedding and a shared villa keep things moving at a brisk, readable clip, close to BookWard's pace.
The blurb leans into cliché while promising a twist, but the core setup is familiar territory, below BookWard's high bar.
Maya's uncertainty about her life and Conor's concealed secret give both some interior, though romance leads rarely run very deep.
Longing and a summer fling invite warmth and feeling, more sentimental than BookWard's restrained preference.
This is not a book that trades on darkness for effect, so any drama is earned through the romance itself.
Not applicable to a work of fiction.
Hazelwood is known for a recognizable, banter-heavy romance style, giving the book a distinct voice.
This is firmly story-led, driven by the relationship rather than any argument or idea.
The age gap and its complications are voiced by the characters themselves, leaning on explaining more than BookWard prefers.
A single-setting week with an escalating wedding gives the middle a steady engine, though romances can drift.
Romance of this kind favors accessible, conversational prose over ornament, plainer than BookWard's middle position.
The story hinges on Maya and Conor's feelings and secrets, so character drives it more than plot machinery.
A summer romance with a promised fling points toward warmth and a happy outlook, above BookWard's.
Banter and a wedding gone sideways suggest a lighter, humorous tone that lands near BookWard's taste.
Easy, breezy reading that asks little effort, well below BookWard's demanding middle.
A grounded contemporary setting with no fantastical elements, more real-world than BookWard's middle.
A wedding party gives it a moderate group, though the focus stays on two leads, close to BookWard's size.
This is an intimate story about two people during one summer, more personal than BookWard's middle.
Maya's feelings and suspicions drive much of the story, so it leans toward inner thoughts.
The relationship between Maya and Conor is the whole spine of the book, the strongest possible fit.
A Sicilian villa among ruins, caves and good food feels unfamiliar to many readers, near BookWard's taste.
A present-day contemporary romance, matching BookWard's preference for the modern.
Trend-aware contemporary romance tends to feel of its moment more than lasting, below BookWard's staying-power taste.
The age-gap tension is acknowledged openly, but the book treats it with fairly clear moral footing.
Ruins, coast, caves and food are central to the setting, giving it richer description than BookWard's middle.
Not applicable to a work of fiction.
Close, intimate narration keeps the perspective personal, more so than BookWard's middle.
It follows Deep End in the author's output but reads as a standalone love story.
The blurb promises clichés becoming plot twists and a hidden secret, giving a handful of surprises below BookWard's taste.
A comfort read built for easy enjoyment, far from BookWard's taste for challenge.
A warm summer romance keeps its content gentle, lighter than BookWard's middle.
Longing and a fraught crush make the feelings strong, near BookWard's intensity.
Banter-driven romance humor leans broader and more playful than dry.
The promised summer fling suggests meaningful sexual content, above BookWard's middle.
Politics are absent from a story about a wedding and a romance.
Plain, accessible language with no dense dialect, easier than BookWard's middle.
A confident, wry narrator voice gives the telling some attitude, matching BookWard's taste.
A romance looking toward a shared future leans forward, close to BookWard's outlook.
A love-conquers-obstacles story is idealistic, above BookWard's middle.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Problematic Summer Romance right for?
Best suited to adult readers of contemporary romance. It involves an age-gap relationship and a fling that includes sexual content.
Easy, breezy reading that asks little effort, well below BookWard's demanding middle.
A warm summer romance keeps its content gentle, lighter than BookWard's middle.
Longing and a fraught crush make the feelings strong, near BookWard's intensity.
Problematic Summer Romance: ideas, characters, themes
A grad student and her brother's best friend, thrown together at a Sicilian wedding, must decide whether a problematic summer fling is worth the risk.
- The age gap. Maya is twenty-three and Conor thirty-eight, and both acknowledge the power imbalance between them.
- Brother's best friend. Conor is Eli Killgore's friend, which adds a layer of complication to any attraction.
- The villa in Taormina. Maya and Conor share a Sicilian villa for over a week, forcing close company.
- A wedding out of control. As Eli's destination wedding grows chaotic, the pressure on Maya and Conor intensifies.
- Conor's possible secret. Maya begins to suspect Conor is hiding something from her.
Characters
Maya Killgore
Protagonist
A twenty-three-year-old grad student still figuring out her life and unable to stop thinking about Conor.
Conor Harkness
Love interest
A thirty-eight-year-old biotech professional and Eli's best friend, who insists a relationship would be problematic.
Eli Killgore
Maya's brother
The groom whose destination wedding in Taormina brings everyone together.
Themes
Desire that both characters know carries risk and judgment.
How an imbalance in experience and status shapes a relationship.
A slow shift from familiar closeness into something more.
Maya's search for direction while navigating her feelings.
What is withheld between two people and how it affects trust.
Discussion questions
- Do the characters' own acknowledgments of the power imbalance change how you read their relationship?
- How does the Sicilian setting shape the way the romance unfolds?
- Which familiar romance tropes does the book lean on, and which does it try to subvert?
- What role does Eli's wedding play in pushing Maya and Conor together?
- Is a summer fling ever just a summer fling, and what does the book suggest?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Problematic Summer Romance
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Problematic Summer Romance
A steamy Stanford sports romance that trades on familiar pleasures
Love TheoreticallyAli HazelwoodA fake-girlfriend rom-com set in the cutthroat world of academic physics
This Summer Will Be DifferentCarley FortuneA summer-fling romance on Prince Edward Island that keeps its promises
Right MoveLiz TomfordeA fake-dating NBA romance that trades on familiar, well-loved tropes
Sources: Open Library.
Track Problematic Summer Romance and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.