
This Summer Will Be Different
by Carley Fortune · 2024
Suits adult readers of contemporary romance who want a light, warm story.
Depends on the edition you pick.
A summer-fling romance on Prince Edward Island that keeps its promises. 51% taste match
The story
This Summer Will Be Different is a 2024 romance novel by Carley Fortune, shelved with literary and general fiction. It is set on Prince Edward Island, where a beach house, red cliffs, fresh oysters and chilled vinho verde frame the seaside backdrop of each visit.
Lucy comes to the island every year to spend time with her best friend, Bridget. She begins each trip with a long walk along the shore, and she also makes herself a promise that she will stay away from Felix, a local man she keeps ending up with. Their first meeting happened before she realized he was Bridget's younger brother, and the two agreed never to repeat that night. Staying apart has proved far harder than agreeing to it. Lucy has always insisted that her heart stays out of the arrangement, even as the attraction between them keeps pulling her back.
The story picks up when Bridget leaves Toronto a week before her wedding. Lucy drops everything and follows her friend to the island, intending to support her through the crisis while holding Felix at a distance. The book follows a friendship, a family connection and a recurring summer pull between two people who keep trying to do the sensible thing.
By the numbers
- Open Library tracks 5 editions from 3 publishers.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 12% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Library of Congress class PR-9199.40000000.F678T48.
A summer-fling romance on Prince Edward Island that keeps its promises
This Summer Will Be Different is a 2024 romance built on a familiar, well-loved setup: best friend's younger brother, a vow to stay apart, and a beach house that makes vows hard to keep. It leans on tropes by design, and it hooks at once with a premise you can grasp in a sentence. Lucy and Felix carry the weight, which makes it a character-driven book, and the romance is central rather than a side thread. Expect a hopeful outlook, a seaside setting rich in food and coastline, and an ending that pays off what the title promises. It is light, warm and comfortable, a different appetite from the one that craves the original and the strictly airtight.
A standalone contemporary romance of ordinary novel length, shorter than sprawling, though not as tight as BookWard prefers.
The wedding-week crisis keeps events moving, a comfortable pace that sits a little under BookWard's brisk preference.
The genre scaffolding is familiar; the Prince Edward Island setting is the freshest ingredient, which falls short of BookWard's taste.
Plain, readable and unshowy prose, a little plainer than BookWard's middle-leaning taste.
The book runs on what Lucy and Felix feel and what they do about it, matching BookWard's character-driven lean.
Romance structure and a sunny island setting point toward an optimistic outlook, a good fit with BookWard.
Flirty banter and light comic touches give it a playful tone, close to BookWard's leaning toward humor.
Gentle and warm, with a bit of heartache but nothing grim, below BookWard's middle.
Longing and heartache give it genuine feeling without tipping into melodrama, similar to BookWard's range.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
- Shock for effectBookWard 9 · book 8
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 2
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 3
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
- OriginalityBookWard 9 · book 3
A standalone contemporary romance of ordinary novel length, shorter than sprawling, though not as tight as BookWard prefers.
The forbidden-attraction premise is clear from the first pages, which matches BookWard's love of an immediate pull.
Best friend's brother and a repeated vow to stay apart are well-worn romance tropes, which cuts against BookWard's taste.
The setup runs on clear cause and effect, though romance conventions ask for some goodwill that BookWard would rather not give.
The wedding-week crisis keeps events moving, a comfortable pace that sits a little under BookWard's brisk preference.
The genre scaffolding is familiar; the Prince Edward Island setting is the freshest ingredient, which falls short of BookWard's taste.
Lucy's guarded heart gives the book real emotional interior, moderately drawn rather than deeply layered.
Romance of this kind promises a satisfying resolution, which suits BookWard's liking for endings that land cleanly.
Warm and openly romantic, it embraces feeling, which sits on the sentimental side of BookWard's restrained taste.
Its drama comes from relationships rather than shock value, so it never leans on cheap darkness, in line with BookWard.
This is fiction, so rigor does not apply.
Fortune writes in a breezy, recognizable romance register, pleasant without being strikingly singular.
This is entirely story-led, driven by relationships rather than ideas, further from BookWard's idea-leaning side.
Feeling and backstory come through scenes and conversation, mostly shown, in step with BookWard.
A single crisis anchors the stay and keeps momentum, though romances can drift between big moments.
Plain, readable and unshowy prose, a little plainer than BookWard's middle-leaning taste.
The book runs on what Lucy and Felix feel and what they do about it, matching BookWard's character-driven lean.
Romance structure and a sunny island setting point toward an optimistic outlook, a good fit with BookWard.
Flirty banter and light comic touches give it a playful tone, close to BookWard's leaning toward humor.
Easy, welcoming reading with no density or puzzle to solve, which is easier than BookWard usually seeks.
The story centers on Lucy's pull toward Felix, so it stays close to a narrow set of perspectives.
Past visits inform the present, but the main story moves forward in a straightforward line.
A contemporary grounded romance with no fantastical element, unlike BookWard's mild interest in the strange.
A small circle of Lucy, Felix and Bridget, with the family connection at the center, a tidy cast like BookWard's.
An intimate story about a friendship, a family and one island summer, smaller in scale than BookWard's middle.
Lucy's feelings and denial drive much of it, tilting toward inner thought over outward action.
Banter and confrontation carry a lot of the attraction, so conversation is prominent, like BookWard's taste.
The romance is the whole point: the Lucy and Felix attraction is the engine of the book.
Prince Edward Island in summer is a specific, appealing locale, fairly unfamiliar for many readers like BookWard.
A present-day contemporary setting, matching BookWard's lean toward the current moment.
A seasonal, genre-pleasing romance more of its moment than lasting, below BookWard's high regard for staying power.
A straightforward romantic narration with no sign of an unreliable teller, at odds with BookWard's liking for unreliability.
The dilemma of a friend's brother is clear and easily weighed rather than morally knotty, unlike BookWard's ambiguity.
Red cliffs, oysters, wine and beach-house settings are described in appetizing detail, richer than BookWard usually likes.
This is fiction, so nonfiction style does not apply.
This is fiction, so nonfiction perspective does not apply.
It reads as a standalone romance, in line with BookWard's lean toward self-contained books.
Romance runs on expected beats, so surprises are mild, lower than BookWard's taste for them.
A comfort read built to soothe and charm, far from the challenge BookWard leans toward.
Gentle and warm, with a bit of heartache but nothing grim, below BookWard's middle.
Longing and heartache give it genuine feeling without tipping into melodrama, similar to BookWard's range.
Flirty, bantering humor sits in the middle, neither dry nor broad, matching BookWard's balance.
A romance with no violence on the page, lighter than BookWard's middle.
The attraction and past nights between Lucy and Felix make intimacy a real part of the story, moderate for BookWard.
Politics do not enter this seaside friendship-and-love story.
Plain accessible language with no dense dialect, easier than BookWard's middle.
Narration leans toward feeling and perspective on Lucy's love life, slightly less opinionated than BookWard likes.
Looks at what a summer fling could grow into, balanced between past visits and future hopes.
Romance faith in love winning out makes it idealistic, a good match with BookWard's idealistic lean.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is This Summer Will Be Different right for?
Suits adult readers of contemporary romance who want a light, warm story. It includes sexual attraction and past intimacy, so it is not aimed at younger teens.
Easy, welcoming reading with no density or puzzle to solve, which is easier than BookWard usually seeks.
Gentle and warm, with a bit of heartache but nothing grim, below BookWard's middle.
Longing and heartache give it genuine feeling without tipping into melodrama, similar to BookWard's range.
A romance with no violence on the page, lighter than BookWard's middle.
This Summer Will Be Different: ideas, characters, themes
Two people who keep promising to stay apart keep returning to the same island and the same pull, and the summer tests whether their promises can hold.
- The setup. Lucy meets Felix as a tourist on Prince Edward Island before learning he is her best friend's younger brother.
- The promise. Each year she resolves not to end up with him, and each year that resolve is tested.
- The heart question. Lucy insists her heart stays out of it, even as Felix seems changed in ways she did not expect.
- The crisis. Bridget leaves Toronto a week before her wedding, and Lucy follows her to the island.
- The setting. Red cliffs, fresh oysters, vinho verde and beach walks shape the mood of every visit.
Characters
Lucy
Annual summer visitor
She drops everything to support her best friend while trying to resist Felix.
Felix
The local she can't resist
The island local whose flirty charm has started to give way to something new.
Bridget
Lucy's best friend and Felix's older sister
She flees Toronto a week before her wedding, bringing Lucy back to the island.
Themes
The pull of what you have promised yourself to avoid.
What you owe a best friend when your wants complicate it.
How a connection to someone's brother raises the stakes of a romance.
Keeping feelings out of an arrangement until they will not stay out.
How a yearly holiday spot becomes a refuge and a trap.
Discussion questions
- Why does Lucy keep making promises she can't keep?
- How does the best-friend connection raise the stakes of the attraction?
- What makes Prince Edward Island more than just a backdrop?
- Is it believable that Lucy can keep her heart out of it?
- How does Bridget's crisis change what Lucy and Felix do?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow This Summer Will Be Different
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked This Summer Will Be Different
A summer fake-dating romance that trades on familiar, comforting moves
Late BloomerMazey EddingsA forced-proximity farm romance with a lottery-winner twist
Au Pair AffairTessa BaileyA warm, familiar nanny romance with a hockey dad and a rift
Problematic Summer RomanceAli HazelwoodA Sicilian wedding week where a forbidden crush finally has nowhere to hide
Sources: Open Library.
Track This Summer Will Be Different and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.