
Once Upon a Broken Heart
by Stephanie Garber
★ Top 25 book of 2021 · #14 on Best Books of 2021
Evangeline Fox believes in true love until she learns her beloved will marry someone else. She bargains with the wicked Prince of Hearts for three kisses, only to discover he wants far more than she promised.
Best for: Readers who enjoy romantic fantasy with dangerous bargains and immortal tricksters
Once Upon a Broken Heart is #14 on BookWard's Best Books of 2021, out of 60 2021 books that cleared our data bar.
What Once Upon a Broken Heart is about
Evangeline Fox has always believed in true love and happy endings. Then she learns that the love of her life is going to marry someone else. Determined to stop the wedding and mend her wounded heart, she makes a bargain with the charismatic and wicked Prince of Hearts. His price is three kisses, to be claimed at a time and place of his choosing. After the first, Evangeline discovers that striking deals with an immortal is a risky business, and that he wants far more from her than she agreed to give. This fairy-tale fantasy of heartbreak and dangerous promises will suit readers who like their romance dark, glittering and uncertain.
Once Upon a Broken Heart on the Best Books of 2021
Once Upon a Broken Heart came out in 2021. Of the 60 books first published in 2021 that met BookWard's data bar, it ranks #14 on our Best Books of 2021 list.
Why it made the list: 1,289 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 3.8 out of 5 (51 ratings); 66 are reading it right now. The list ranks each year’s books on how many readers have picked them up, how highly readers rate them, and how many are reading them right now.
Nearby on the 2021 list
- Haunting Adeline H. D. Carlton, #12
- Better Than the Movies Lynn Painter, #13
- Heartstopper, Volume 4 Alice Oseman, #15
- You'd Be Home Now Kathleen Glasgow, #16
See all Best Books of 2021 Best books by year
More years: Best Books of 2020 Best Books of 2022.
The numbers behind it
- Readers: 1,161 want to read it, 66 are reading it now and 62 have read it, according to Open Library.
- Ratings: 3.8 out of 5 from 51 Open Library ratings.
| Signal | This book (0 to 100) | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Reach | 85 | 55% |
| Reader love | 42 | 25% |
| Being read right now | 85 | 20% |
Questions about Once Upon a Broken Heart
When was Once Upon a Broken Heart published?
Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber was first published in 2021.
Was Once Upon a Broken Heart one of the best books of 2021?
Once Upon a Broken Heart is #14 on BookWard's Best Books of 2021, out of 60 2021 books that cleared our data bar. 1,289 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 3.8 out of 5 (51 ratings); 66 are reading it right now.
Why is Once Upon a Broken Heart on the Best Books of 2021 list?
1,289 readers have shelved it on Open Library; readers rate it 3.8 out of 5 (51 ratings); 66 are reading it right now.
More of the best books of 2021
- The Love Hypothesis Ali Hazelwood, #1
- Twisted Games Ana Huang, #2
- Project Hail Mary Andy Weir, #3
- As Good as Dead Holly Jackson, #4
- You've Reached Sam Dustin Thao, #5
- Twisted Love Ana Huang, #6
See the full Best Books of 2021, the Top 100, or new books on Rising.
How we know
This page uses public data: Open Library reader counts and ratings, and Wikipedia page views for recent years. The description is paraphrased from real source text. Rankings reflect reading interest, not quality or sales, and can be affected by data gaps. Lists update monthly.
Suits older teens and adults who enjoy romantic fantasy.
Depends on the edition you pick.
A lush fairy-tale romance where every bargain has teeth. 46% taste match
A lush fairy-tale romance where every bargain has teeth
Evangeline Fox believes in happy endings until the man she loves is set to marry someone else, so she bargains with the Prince of Hearts for three kisses. Garber builds a fantasy world that is rich in description and fairy-tale gloss, and the premise grabs you at once, which suits a reader who loves a fast hook. The prose is more ornate than I usually like, and romance sits near the center of the story, not at the edge. Familiar tropes are part of the pleasure here, so it may not win over readers who want them subverted, but it will suit anyone who enjoys a bargain with an immortal done with style. It is also the first of a series, so expect threads left open.
Moves briskly from deal to deal, close to BookWard's quick-paced preference.
The three-kiss bargain is a fresh hook, but the broader shape is well-worn romantic fantasy, short of BookWard's high bar.
Lush, jewel-toned and decorative prose that is noticeably more ornate than BookWard's middling taste.
Plot and character share the load, since the bargains drive events and Evangeline's longing shapes every choice.
Built on belief in true love and happy endings, it keeps a hopeful current even when things turn dark.
A conventional linear quest told in sequence, plainer in design than BookWard's slightly adventurous lean.
A romantic fairy tale played earnestly, with lightness here and there but little in the way of comedy.
Fairy-tale peril and a wicked prince add shadow, but it stays within young-adult-friendly bounds.
Heartbreak, longing and desire run high throughout.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- OpeningBookWard 10 · book 9
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 7
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 2
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 4
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 5
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
A broken-hearted heroine striking a deal with the Prince of Hearts gives the book an immediate pull, right where BookWard likes to start.
Fairy-tale bargains, immortal princes and love triangles are familiar territory, so it leans on tropes more than BookWard usually likes.
Magical bargains follow rules that carry consequences, though the fairy-tale logic bends more than BookWard's airtight ideal.
Moves briskly from deal to deal, close to BookWard's quick-paced preference.
The three-kiss bargain is a fresh hook, but the broader shape is well-worn romantic fantasy, short of BookWard's high bar.
Evangeline's hopes and heartbreak are clearly drawn, though the supporting figures lean toward fairy-tale archetypes.
As the opening of a series, it leaves threads dangling, which sits looser than BookWard's resolved endings.
Its heart-on-sleeve romance and happily-ever-after longing run warmer than BookWard's restrained taste.
The darkness serves the fairy-tale stakes and consequences of the bargains, though the twists lean toward dramatic effect.
Not applicable to a novel.
Garber's storybook narration has a recognizable, sugared-fairy-tale flavor that stands apart from generic fantasy.
This is story all the way, driven by bargains and romance, which matches BookWard's story-led lean.
Magic and its rules are mostly revealed through scenes and bargains, though some world lore is explained outright.
The bargain structure gives a steady forward push, with only occasional lulls between set pieces.
Lush, jewel-toned and decorative prose that is noticeably more ornate than BookWard's middling taste.
Plot and character share the load, since the bargains drive events and Evangeline's longing shapes every choice.
Built on belief in true love and happy endings, it keeps a hopeful current even when things turn dark.
A conventional linear quest told in sequence, plainer in design than BookWard's slightly adventurous lean.
A romantic fairy tale played earnestly, with lightness here and there but little in the way of comedy.
Easy to read, with clear stakes and an inviting style that asks little of the reader.
The story is anchored in Evangeline's experience, so it stays close to one perspective.
Events unfold in order, with no heavy time-shifting.
Immortals, magic and fairy-tale kingdoms put it at the fully fantastical end of the scale.
A heroine, a prince and a handful of other key figures keep the cast compact.
Stakes center on one woman's heart and bargains, though the magic world gives a wider backdrop.
Evangeline's feelings and her bargains share the stage in roughly equal measure.
Charged exchanges with the Prince of Hearts carry much of the tension and charm.
Romance is the engine of the story, from the lost love to the three promised kisses.
An invented fairy-tale realm full of immortals and magic, far from the familiar.
A made-up storybook setting, so present-day concerns sit far away.
Fairy-tale framing gives it some lasting appeal, though it is also firmly a modern romantic fantasy.
The narration is straightforward and trustworthy, in a classic storyteller mode.
Choices carry clear costs, though bargains with immortals add some shades of gray.
Rich, sensory, jewel-bright description is a hallmark of the world.
Not applicable to a novel.
Not applicable to a novel.
It opens a series, so the story reaches beyond a single volume.
Bargains and hidden motives keep revelations coming, in line with BookWard's taste for surprises.
A comforting, escapist read with romantic payoffs, easier on the reader than challenging.
Fairy-tale peril and a wicked prince add shadow, but it stays within young-adult-friendly bounds.
Heartbreak, longing and desire run high throughout.
What humor appears is light and playful, nothing broad.
Danger is present in the magic and bargains, but not graphically on the page.
Kisses and romantic tension carry the heat, with little explicit content.
Concerns are personal and magical, not political.
Plain, accessible language with ornamental flourishes but no dense dialect.
The narration tells the tale without pressing opinions on the reader.
Looks forward through hope for a happily ever after, tempered by the pull of past loves.
A firm belief in true love and happy endings drives the heroine and the book.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Once Upon a Broken Heart right for?
Suits older teens and adults who enjoy romantic fantasy. Expect romantic tension, fairy-tale peril and emotional intensity but little graphic content.
Easy to read, with clear stakes and an inviting style that asks little of the reader.
Fairy-tale peril and a wicked prince add shadow, but it stays within young-adult-friendly bounds.
Heartbreak, longing and desire run high throughout.
Danger is present in the magic and bargains, but not graphically on the page.
Once Upon a Broken Heart: ideas, characters, themes
A woman who believes in true love makes a dangerous deal with an immortal prince to mend her heart.
- A bargain with consequences. Evangeline trades three kisses for the Prince of Hearts' help, and the deal grows more dangerous than she expects.
- Love as motivation. Her belief in true love and happy endings drives every decision she makes.
- A storybook world. The setting is a fairy-tale realm of magic and immortals, told in rich and decorative detail.
- Romance at the center. The relationship between Evangeline and the prince is the engine of the plot.
- The first of a series. It begins a larger story, so some questions carry beyond this book.
Characters
Evangeline Fox
Protagonist
A believer in true love and happy endings whose heartbreak sets the story in motion.
The Prince of Hearts
Charismatic immortal
A wicked, magnetic figure who offers Evangeline help in exchange for three kisses.
Themes
How far people will go for the person they love.
Every wish granted by magic carries a price.
The pull of happily ever after and what it asks of us.
How pain pushes characters toward risky choices.
Discussion questions
- How far would you go for your own happily ever after?
- Is Evangeline's belief in true love a strength, a weakness or both?
- What makes the Prince of Hearts appealing and dangerous at once?
- How does a bargain with an immortal change the way you read the stakes?
- Does the fairy-tale style make the story feel cozier or more menacing?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Once Upon a Broken Heart
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Once Upon a Broken Heart
Caraval's second round: a sister's bargain and a dangerous game
A Curse for True LoveStephanie GarberA romantic fairytale finale that leans on beloved tropes
Clockwork AngelCassandra ClareVictorian London, demon hunters, and a love triangle with teeth
WisteriaAdalyn GraceA gothic romantasy finale that wants you invested in the series
Find your own best books
Add what you have read, rate it, and BookWard will recommend what to read next.
Free to start. No credit card needed.