Best suited to adult readers who enjoy domestic suspense and psychological thrillers.
336 pages, about 5.5 to 8 hours.
A nanny, a lie, and a perfect family hiding more. 64% taste match
The story
Count My Lies is a psychological thriller by Sophie Stava, first published in 2025. Running to roughly 336 pages, it belongs to the mystery and suspense category and sits within American literature. The story is set in New York and follows Sloane Caraway, a woman who tells small untruths to make her own life feel more interesting.
One afternoon in a park, Sloane meets a young girl crying over a bee sting. Claiming to be a nurse, she helps the girl's father remove the stinger. That single invention leads to a job as nanny for Jay and Violet Lockhart, a wealthy couple who live in a brownstone, send their daughter to private school, and spend summers on Block Island.
From there the novel turns to the households and images people work to keep up, and to the secrets that sit behind them. Sloane is not the only person in the Lockhart orbit who may be hiding something, and the neat surface of the family's life carries a darker side. The book looks at how falsehoods accumulate and shape the worlds built around them, and it has appeared in four editions.
Themes
American literatureThrillerSuspensePsychological thrillerMystery
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 336 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 6.2 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 4 editions from 2 publishers.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 56% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Dewey 813.6 and Library of Congress class PS-3619.00000000.T3847C68 2025.
A nanny, a lie, and a perfect family hiding more
Count My Lies starts with a small fib in a park and wastes no time turning it into a job, a brownstone and a household with something to hide. The premise pulls you in at once, and that kind of immediate hook counts for a lot. It is a psychological thriller built on pace and surprises, and at 336 pages it stays reasonably tight and short. The gamble is that it leans on familiar tropes. The nanny in a wealthy home is well-trodden ground, so how much the book earns its twists matters more than the setup. Character depth hangs on Sloane, a liar whose narration is worth watching closely. The test will be whether everything adds up, since a lie-driven plot lives or dies on its internal logic.
At 336 pages it is compact for a thriller, which suits BookWard's taste for tight books.
Billed as breakneck and unputdownable, it should move quickly, in line with BookWard's preference.
The premise is a recognisable thriller shape, with originality resting on how the lies play out.
Commercial thriller prose tends toward clean and plain, which keeps the pages turning.
The lie-driven plot leads, with Sloane's character feeding it, so it leans toward plot-driven.
A story about deception and hidden danger leans bleak rather than hopeful.
The setup points to a conventional linear thriller structure.
It is billed as bitingly smart, so some dark wit is present, but the book is mainly serious.
A dangerous truth sits beneath the surface, but the tone is suspense, not extremity.
The pull is tension and dread more than raw feeling.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 8
- SentimentBookWard 8 · book 8
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 4
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 7
- OriginalityBookWard 9 · book 5
At 336 pages it is compact for a thriller, which suits BookWard's taste for tight books.
A white lie in a park sets the whole plot moving almost immediately, matching BookWard's love of an instant hook.
The nanny in a wealthy household is familiar territory, so the book sits below BookWard's tolerance for tropes.
A story built on accumulating lies needs tight mechanics to work, and the premise is designed around cause and consequence.
Billed as breakneck and unputdownable, it should move quickly, in line with BookWard's preference.
The premise is a recognisable thriller shape, with originality resting on how the lies play out.
Sloane's self-image and compulsive lying give the book a real character to work with, though it is plot-first.
Thrillers of this kind tend to deliver a clear reveal, which fits BookWard's liking for resolution.
A cold-eyed suspense story about image and deceit has little room for softness, which BookWard appreciates.
The darker truth under the family's polish is the engine, and whether it feels earned is the open question.
This is fiction, so rigor does not apply.
A narrator who lies about herself invites a strong, distinctive voice, though that remains to be proven.
This is a story-led thriller, close to BookWard's own preference for plot over argument.
Suspense fiction usually lets events and secrets surface through scenes rather than explanation.
A short, fast thriller has less room to sag, and the premise keeps escalating.
Commercial thriller prose tends toward clean and plain, which keeps the pages turning.
The lie-driven plot leads, with Sloane's character feeding it, so it leans toward plot-driven.
A story about deception and hidden danger leans bleak rather than hopeful.
The setup points to a conventional linear thriller structure.
It is billed as bitingly smart, so some dark wit is present, but the book is mainly serious.
A page-turning thriller is an easy read that does not ask for much effort.
A New York thriller about nannies and brownstones is firmly grounded.
The story is intimate, confined to one family and one city.
Sloane's lies and the family's secrets balance inner life with unfolding events.
Domestic suspense relies on conversations where people size each other up, so dialogue carries a fair load.
Sloane's attraction to the father is present in the setup but not the main thrust.
New York wealth is a familiar setting in fiction, though the household's inner workings may be less so.
Published in 2025 and set among modern New York privilege, it is thoroughly contemporary.
A thriller about image and lies has some lasting appeal but is rooted in its moment.
A protagonist defined by lying is a natural fit for an unreliable narrator.
With a liar at the centre and a polished family concealing danger, nobody is clean.
Brownstones and summers on Block Island matter, but thriller description tends to stay lean.
It reads as a standalone novel.
The book promises a twisty plot where hidden truths keep surfacing.
Tense and unsettling, it leans uncomfortable more than comforting.
A dangerous truth sits beneath the surface, but the tone is suspense, not extremity.
The pull is tension and dread more than raw feeling.
Any humor is likely to be dry and biting rather than broad.
Sloane's interest in the father adds some, but it is not the focus.
The class gap between nanny and wealthy employers touches social themes without making politics central.
Contemporary commercial prose keeps the language plain.
A narrator with a point of view and a talent for spin colours everything she tells.
The book is anchored in the present with little pull toward past or future.
A world of curated images and lies is cynical at heart.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Count My Lies right for?
Best suited to adult readers who enjoy domestic suspense and psychological thrillers. Expect tension, deception and a darker side to the household; check content notes if violence or sexual content concern you.
A page-turning thriller is an easy read that does not ask for much effort.
A dangerous truth sits beneath the surface, but the tone is suspense, not extremity.
The pull is tension and dread more than raw feeling.
Count My Lies: ideas, characters, themes
A woman's small lie wins her a place inside a wealthy family, and the lies on both sides begin to add up.
- A lie opens the door. Sloane claims to be a nurse in a park, and that invention leads to a nanny job.
- The Lockhart household. Jay and Violet Lockhart live in a brownstone, send their daughter to private school and spend summers on Block Island.
- Lies compound. The book follows how falsehoods accumulate and build their own version of the truth.
- Not the only liar. Sloane is not the only person who may be hiding something around the family.
- Image versus reality. The polished surface of an ideal New York family sits against a more dangerous truth.
Characters
Sloane Caraway
Protagonist and nanny
A habitual liar who tells small untruths to make her life feel more interesting.
Jay Lockhart
Wealthy father
The girl's father, whom Sloane meets in the park and helps with the bee sting.
Violet Lockhart
Jay's wife
Half of the seemingly perfect New York couple Sloane goes to work for.
Themes
How small falsehoods grow and trap the people who tell them.
The effort people put into maintaining a polished public surface.
What families and individuals hide, and what it costs to keep hiding it.
The gap between a struggling nanny and the wealthy household she enters.
Discussion questions
- Why does Sloane's first lie feel harmless, and when does it stop being so?
- Does the Lockharts' perfect image make their secrets more or less believable?
- How much should we trust a narrator who admits to lying?
- What does the nanny's position reveal about class in the story?
- Do the twists feel earned or are they there for shock?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Count My Lies
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Count My Lies
An advice columnist stops advising and starts avenging
Listen for the LieAmy TinteraA true crime podcast drags a woman back to her own murder case
You Are Fatally InvitedAnde PliegoA locked-room thriller about thriller writers, with a murder plot gone wrong
When I Kill YouB.A. ParisA stalker thriller where the watched may once have been the watcher
Sources: Open Library.
Track Count My Lies and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.