What Have You Done?
by Shari Lapeña · 2024
Suits readers who enjoy crime thrillers.
376 pages, about 6 to 9 hours.
A small Vermont town turns on itself after one girl's death. 51% taste match
The story
What Have You Done? is a 2024 novel by Shari Lapeña, filed under literary and general fiction. It runs to roughly 376 pages and is set in Fairhill, Vermont, a small town where neighbors know one another and doors are rarely locked.
The story begins when a farmer finds Diana Brewer lying in a hayfield, dead, with vultures gathered around her. She was a girl who should have been at home in bed. Her death turns Fairhill upside down. The residents who have always trusted one another begin to regard each other with suspicion, and fear takes hold of the community as people press for an explanation. Someone in the town is responsible, and the question of who it is hangs over everyone, from the teenagers who tell ghost stories in the old graveyard to the parents who assumed their children were safe.
This is a mystery of a small community under strain, where familiar faces become suspects in the wake of a single death.
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 376 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 6.9 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 6 editions from 4 publishers, the earliest dated 2024 and the latest 2025.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 57% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Dewey 813.6 and Library of Congress class PR-9199.40000000.L366W47.
A small Vermont town turns on itself after one girl's death
Shari Lapeña drops a body in the first pages and lets a quiet Vermont town start eyeing its own neighbors. The opening hooks at once: Diana Brewer, found in a hayfield, and a question that lands on everyone. The pace is brisk, which works in its favor, and the many-suspects shape of a small-town mystery tends to keep a middle from sagging. Where it falters is in familiar tropes and a lack of originality, since the unlocked-doors community where everyone knows everyone is well-trodden ground. Expect plot to lead and ideas to stay light, with a question the story is built to answer. A page-turner built for momentum rather than depth.
At 376 pages it is mid-length for a thriller, longer than BookWard's love of the tight and short.
A question hanging over the whole town keeps things moving quickly, in step with BookWard's fast-pace preference.
The premise is a well-worn small-town mystery, less original than BookWard prefers.
Plain, quick prose serves the page-turning mood and sits plainer than BookWard's middle ground.
The mystery drives events, so this is more plot-led than BookWard's character-driven lean.
A town turning to fear and paranoia keeps the mood bleak more than BookWard's hopeful outlook.
A conventional crime structure built around finding the culprit, close to BookWard's modest taste for structure.
This is a serious, tense book with little comedy, far from BookWard's lean toward humor.
A girl's death and a town of fear make this dark, though not extreme, near BookWard's mid-range.
Suspicion and fear create tension, but the feel is more tense than deeply intense.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 8
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
- OpeningBookWard 10 · book 9
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 3
- OriginalityBookWard 9 · book 3
- Authorial voiceBookWard 9 · book 4
At 376 pages it is mid-length for a thriller, longer than BookWard's love of the tight and short.
A girl found dead in a hayfield opens the story at once, exactly what BookWard wants from a first page.
The close-knit town with unlocked doors where everyone knows everyone is a familiar setup, which sits against BookWard's taste for avoiding tropes.
A question hanging over the whole town keeps things moving quickly, in step with BookWard's fast-pace preference.
The premise is a well-worn small-town mystery, less original than BookWard prefers.
A town full of suspects in a plot-forward thriller tends toward sketched types over deep portraits, below BookWard's bar.
A mystery built on one question is the kind of book that sets out to answer it, which fits BookWard's liking for resolution.
A death opens the book, and the genre leans on revelations for effect more than BookWard's earned-darkness ideal.
This applies to nonfiction only.
Commercial thriller prose is built for clarity and speed, not a standout authorial voice.
This is firmly story-led, a puzzle about who did it rather than a book of ideas, near BookWard's taste.
Mystery fiction mostly reveals through scenes and suspicion, in line with BookWard's preference for showing.
Shifting suspicion across the town gives the middle fresh pressure, though the genre can stall between revelations.
Plain, quick prose serves the page-turning mood and sits plainer than BookWard's middle ground.
The mystery drives events, so this is more plot-led than BookWard's character-driven lean.
A town turning to fear and paranoia keeps the mood bleak more than BookWard's hopeful outlook.
A conventional crime structure built around finding the culprit, close to BookWard's modest taste for structure.
This is a serious, tense book with little comedy, far from BookWard's lean toward humor.
Easy to follow and made to be read fast, easier than BookWard's moderate effort level.
A grounded real-world crime story with nothing supernatural in it.
A whole town of suspects calls for a sizable cast, bigger than BookWard's usual.
The story stays within one small town, an intimate canvas rather than an epic one.
Investigation and suspicion drive the action outward, more than the inner life BookWard leans to.
Suspicion plays out in conversations and confrontations, comfortably dialogue-heavy like BookWard's taste.
A familiar American small town, plainer territory than the unfamiliar settings BookWard enjoys.
A contemporary 2024 novel set in the present day, in line with BookWard's lean to now.
A bestselling thriller of its moment, with less claim to lasting power than BookWard rewards.
A whodunit points toward finding the guilty party, clearer than BookWard's taste for moral ambiguity.
Brisk thriller pacing leaves description lighter than the rich detail BookWard sits near.
This applies to nonfiction only.
This applies to nonfiction only.
A mystery with a whole town of suspects is built on turns and reveals, matching BookWard's liking for surprises.
It is a gripping read for entertainment, more comforting than the challenge BookWard leans toward.
A girl's death and a town of fear make this dark, though not extreme, near BookWard's mid-range.
Suspicion and fear create tension, but the feel is more tense than deeply intense.
There is no real humor in the pitch, so this does not apply.
Plain, accessible language throughout, well below BookWard's middle on language difficulty.
Genre thrillers narrate neutrally and let the plot do the work, less opinionated than BookWard likes.
A mystery turns on a past act and works to uncover it, so it looks back more than forward.
A town sliding into paranoia reads cynical, below BookWard's idealistic lean.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is What Have You Done? right for?
Suits readers who enjoy crime thrillers. It centers on the death of a young girl and the fear that follows, which some readers may find unsettling.
Easy to follow and made to be read fast, easier than BookWard's moderate effort level.
A girl's death and a town of fear make this dark, though not extreme, near BookWard's mid-range.
Suspicion and fear create tension, but the feel is more tense than deeply intense.
What Have You Done?: ideas, characters, themes
When a girl is found dead in a trusting small town, neighbors who never locked their doors start suspecting one another.
- A shocking opening. The story begins with Diana Brewer found in a hayfield, circled by vultures, setting the stakes immediately.
- A town of suspects. Familiar faces become suspects, and trust erodes across Fairhill.
- Fear spreads. Paranoia and fear take hold of a place that felt safe.
- Everyone wants answers. The pressure to explain Diana's death hangs over the whole community.
- Safety questioned. Parents who assumed their children were safe must face that they might not be.
Characters
Diana Brewer
The girl found dead
Her death in a hayfield is what turns Fairhill upside down.
Themes
How quickly confidence in neighbors can break.
Fear turning familiar faces into possible culprits.
A close-knit place tested by a single event.
The fragile belief that a small town keeps its children secure.
Discussion questions
- Why does a close-knit town turn on itself so quickly?
- What makes a small, trusting community vulnerable to fear?
- How does the opening image of Diana in the hayfield shape the mood?
- Which assumptions about safety does the book challenge?
- What do you want from a mystery's answer once the culprit is revealed?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow What Have You Done?
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked What Have You Done?
A hospital thriller where the nurse gets pulled into the mystery
Home Is Where the Bodies AreJeneva RoseA family thriller where old home videos unearth a buried crime
It's Not HerMary KubicaA lakeside double murder opens a domestic thriller built on family secrets
Middle of the NightRiley SagerA suburban cold case with a hook that lands at once
Sources: Open Library.
Track What Have You Done? and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.