
Tell Me What You Did
by Carter Wilson · 2025
Best suited to adult readers comfortable with crime fiction.
430 pages, about 7 to 10 hours.
A podcast host's confession booth turns on its own host. 54% taste match
The story
Tell Me What You Did is a novel by Carter Wilson, first published in 2025 and shelved as literary and general fiction within American literature. It runs to roughly 430 pages and follows a woman whose career rests on listening to other people's worst moments.
Poe Webb hosts a true crime podcast on which guests come forward to admit to crimes they have committed, speaking without their names attached. The format offers them both secrecy and sudden notice from her audience, though Poe cannot promise that police will stay away from those who take part. Once a recording ends, she is in the habit of putting the confession out of her mind.
That routine breaks down when a man who seems oddly familiar joins the show and says he is the person who murdered her mother many years earlier. Poe has her own reasons for doubting him, since she holds private knowledge about what became of that killer. The book centers on her confrontation with this guest and on the secret she has kept to herself.
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 430 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 7.9 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 2 editions from 2 publishers.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 31% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Dewey 813.6 and Library of Congress class PS-3623.00000000.I57787T45.
A podcast host's confession booth turns on its own host
Carter Wilson builds this thriller on a clean, hooky premise: Poe Webb hosts a true crime podcast where people confess anonymously, and one guest claims to be the man who murdered her mother, a man she knows is dead. That setup lands almost at once, and it's the draw here, since a book that grabs you from the first pages earns a lot of goodwill. At 430 pages, though, this runs well past what a tight thriller needs, so the real test is whether the middle holds up or starts to sag. The other question is how much it leans on familiar tropes. The true crime podcast frame is well worn, though the secret at the center gives it a sharper edge. Expect plot to lead and character to follow, with the pull coming from the puzzle rather than from interior life.
At 430 pages it runs longer than a thriller of this kind needs, which cuts against BookWard's love of tight books.
Confession episodes and a looming reveal suggest brisk forward motion, in line with BookWard's taste for speed.
The anonymous-confession podcast is a fresh engine for a thriller, even if the genre around it is well trodden.
Suspense fiction leans plain and functional, which BookWard accepts when the story moves.
The mystery of the confession drives events more than Poe's inner change does.
A murdered mother and a concealed killing keep the outlook on the grim side.
A podcast frame adds a little variety, but the book reads as a conventional thriller in shape.
Murder, secrets and confession leave little room for humor.
Murder, a mother's death and a concealed killing make for dark subject matter.
Grief and fear around a mother's murder keep the stakes personal and charged.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 8
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
- OpeningBookWard 10 · book 9
Where it pulls apart
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 6
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 5
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
At 430 pages it runs longer than a thriller of this kind needs, which cuts against BookWard's love of tight books.
A host who killed the man now confessing to her mother's murder is a premise that grabs immediately, exactly what BookWard wants.
The true crime podcast frame is familiar territory, though the buried secret gives it some edge over the usual formula.
A premise built on a hidden killing needs its secrets to hold together, and a thriller like this is built to be solvable.
Confession episodes and a looming reveal suggest brisk forward motion, in line with BookWard's taste for speed.
The anonymous-confession podcast is a fresh engine for a thriller, even if the genre around it is well trodden.
Poe's guarded past gives her some depth, but the plot pressure tends to pull focus from deep characterization.
Thrillers built around one big secret tend to pay it off, which matches BookWard's liking for resolution.
A murdered mother and a buried killing keep this on the hard-edged side rather than the tender one.
A killing hidden for years is dark by design, and how well it earns that darkness is the open question.
Commercial suspense usually favors momentum over a signature style, so the voice is competent rather than singular.
This is firmly story-led, driven by a secret and a confrontation rather than by an argument.
Podcast episodes and confessions give a natural channel for backstory, so some explaining is built into the form.
With 430 pages, keeping tension taut through the middle is the main risk, and BookWard prizes sustained pace.
Suspense fiction leans plain and functional, which BookWard accepts when the story moves.
The mystery of the confession drives events more than Poe's inner change does.
A murdered mother and a concealed killing keep the outlook on the grim side.
A podcast frame adds a little variety, but the book reads as a conventional thriller in shape.
Murder, secrets and confession leave little room for humor.
Thrillers are built for easy reading, and this one's premise is simple to follow.
The murder happened years ago and the present drives the story, so some looking back is expected.
A grounded crime story with no fantastical element.
This is an intimate, personal conflict rather than an epic canvas.
Poe's secret weighs on her inside while the confrontation plays out in the open, so it splits the difference.
A confessional podcast puts people talking at the center, so dialogue carries weight.
A podcast studio and a crime-haunted past are familiar ground rather than an unfamiliar world.
The podcast setting dates it somewhat, though the core of secrets and guilt travels well.
A heroine who killed and a guest who claims to have killed make for knotted right and wrong.
Thrillers economize on description to keep moving, so setting stays secondary.
It is meant to unsettle and entertain more than to provoke deep reflection.
Murder, a mother's death and a concealed killing make for dark subject matter.
Grief and fear around a mother's murder keep the stakes personal and charged.
Not a funny book, so humor barely registers.
Murder is central to the setup, though much of it sits in the past and in confession.
Crime thrillers of this kind seldom lean on sexual content, and the premise gives no sign this one does.
A crime thriller with no political agenda in view.
Plain, accessible language fits the genre.
Close to Poe's perspective but not preachy, it leans neutral.
Rooted in a past murder resurfacing, it looks back more than forward.
Secrets, killing and confession paint a fairly cynical picture of people.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Tell Me What You Did right for?
Best suited to adult readers comfortable with crime fiction. It deals with murder, a mother's death and a concealed killing.
Thrillers are built for easy reading, and this one's premise is simple to follow.
Murder, a mother's death and a concealed killing make for dark subject matter.
Grief and fear around a mother's murder keep the stakes personal and charged.
Murder is central to the setup, though much of it sits in the past and in confession.
Tell Me What You Did: ideas, characters, themes
A true crime podcaster who elicits anonymous confessions is confronted by a guest claiming to have murdered her mother, a man she knows is dead.
- The confession format. Poe's show offers guests anonymity and sudden fame, though she cannot promise police will stay away.
- Her usual routine. After each recording she tends to erase the criminal and the crime from her mind.
- The familiar guest. A strange, oddly familiar man joins the show and forces her to look again.
- The claim. He says he is her mother's murderer from years ago.
- The secret. Poe holds private knowledge of what became of that killer, and it drives the book.
Characters
Poe Webb
Protagonist
The host of a popular true crime podcast who invites anonymous confessions and carries a secret of her own.
The guest
Antagonist
A strange, oddly familiar man who claims on air to be the man who murdered Poe's mother.
Poe's mother
Past victim
Her murder years ago is the event the guest claims to have committed.
Themes
What people reveal when anonymity removes the cost of speaking.
The weight of acts people try to put out of their minds.
What a person hides and what it costs to keep hiding it.
The fame and exposure that come with speaking publicly about crime.
Discussion questions
- Is Poe a reliable guide to her own story?
- What does anonymity do to people's honesty?
- Is the host responsible for what guests confess?
- How does the true crime podcast frame shape the tension?
- Does the central secret hold up as the story unfolds?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Tell Me What You Did
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Tell Me What You Did
A missing mother returns and the questions get sharper
It's Not HerMary KubicaA lakeside double murder opens a domestic thriller built on family secrets
She's Not SorryMary KubicaA hospital thriller where the nurse gets pulled into the mystery
Home Is Where the Bodies AreJeneva RoseA family thriller where old home videos unearth a buried crime
Sources: Open Library.
Track Tell Me What You Did and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.