
A good fit for adult and mature teen readers who enjoy emotional contemporary romance.
352 pages, about 5.5 to 8 hours.
A love triangle that turns on a husband returning from the dead. 53% taste match
The story
One True Loves is a contemporary romance by Taylor Jenkins Reid, first published in 2016. It follows Emma Blair, who marries her high school sweetheart, Jesse Lerner, in her twenties. The two leave behind the expectations of their families and their Massachusetts hometown and spend their early marriage traveling and chasing adventure. Their first anniversary brings a helicopter flight over the Pacific and a loss that sends Emma back to the town where she grew up.
Years later, Emma reconnects with an old friend, Sam Kemper, and a new relationship takes shape between them. Then news about Jesse changes everything, leaving Emma with a husband and a fiancé and a hard question about what it means to love someone. The story is a love triangle, centered on a woman choosing between two relationships. Its settings include Acton and Boston in Massachusetts, Malibu in California, and the Aleutian Islands in Alaska. The print edition runs to roughly 352 pages.
I am finishing up dinner with my family and my fiancé when my husband calls.
Setting
Acton (Mass.)Boston (Mass.)Malibu (Calif.)Aleutian Islands (Alaska)
Themes
Triangles (Interpersonal relations)Man-woman relationshipsMate selectionNew York Times bestseller
- Want to read 370
- Reading now 21
- Read 35
Most people shelving it are saving it for later.
Of 426 readers who put it on a shelf, 87% want to read it, 5% are reading it now, 8% have finished it and 0% stopped before the end.
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 352 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 6.5 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 6 editions from 5 publishers, the earliest dated 2016 and the latest 2022.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 1% of the recent books in our catalog (6,647 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Library of Congress class PS-3618.00000000.E5478 O54 2016.
A love triangle that turns on a husband returning from the dead
One True Loves puts Emma Blair between her first husband and her fiancé, and it asks what loving someone truly means. The premise is a familiar romance setup, and it leans on well-worn tropes, though the structure around it keeps things moving. It reads fast: the pace is brisk and the opening hooks at once, since the loss comes early. The characters are the real strength here, as Emma's choice is about who she is, not only whom she wants. The ending is resolved rather than left open, which is satisfying. The book isn't especially original, and it runs warm, so it leans more tender than restrained. At 352 pages it stays compact and the middle never sags.
At 352 pages it is a compact read that keeps its focus, which BookWard prefers to sprawl.
Short, emotionally driven chapters keep momentum high, close to the quick pace BookWard enjoys.
The situation of a husband returning after being presumed lost is a known romance device, so it reads as more familiar than fresh.
The prose is clean and conversational, with little ornament, which is easy on the reader.
The plot exists to test Emma's heart, so the book is firmly character-driven, as BookWard likes.
For all the grief, the book looks toward healing and a second chance at happiness.
The book follows a fairly conventional shape, moving from loss to a new love to a complication.
The tone is earnest and emotional, with only light touches of humor.
Grief sits at the center, but the book stays emotionally gentle overall.
Longing, grief and love run high, making this an intensely emotional read.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 8
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
- Character depthBookWard 8 · book 7
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 4
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
- OriginalityBookWard 9 · book 4
At 352 pages it is a compact read that keeps its focus, which BookWard prefers to sprawl.
The loss of Jesse arrives early, so the story grabs attention quickly, matching what BookWard wants from an opening.
A love triangle is well-worn romance ground, so the premise leans on familiar tropes, which counts against it for BookWard.
The setup holds together well enough for the emotional story, though the central situation asks for some suspension of disbelief.
Short, emotionally driven chapters keep momentum high, close to the quick pace BookWard enjoys.
The situation of a husband returning after being presumed lost is a known romance device, so it reads as more familiar than fresh.
Emma's inner conflict carries the book and gives her real weight, which BookWard values.
The story is built around a decision, and it delivers a clear resolution rather than leaving things hanging.
The book embraces feeling openly and warmly, which makes it more sentimental than the restraint BookWard prefers.
The central turn is dramatic, but it serves the emotional question rather than existing only to shock.
This is fiction, so the dial does not apply.
Reid writes in an accessible, recognizable style, pleasant and personal but not strikingly singular.
This is a story-led novel built around Emma's relationships and choices, not around an argument.
Emotion and backstory are often stated plainly, so the book explains more than BookWard likes.
The compact length and a strong central dilemma keep the middle moving without much drag.
The prose is clean and conversational, with little ornament, which is easy on the reader.
The plot exists to test Emma's heart, so the book is firmly character-driven, as BookWard likes.
For all the grief, the book looks toward healing and a second chance at happiness.
The book follows a fairly conventional shape, moving from loss to a new love to a complication.
The tone is earnest and emotional, with only light touches of humor.
It is an easy, absorbing read that asks little of the reader beyond attention.
The story stays close to Emma, giving it a single, intimate viewpoint.
The narrative moves between Emma's past with Jesse and her present, so it shifts in time.
The story is grounded in real places and everyday emotional life.
A small circle of central figures, mainly Emma, Jesse and Sam, carries the story.
The stakes are personal and domestic, centered on one woman's heart.
Emma's feelings and decisions drive the book far more than outward action.
Conversations between Emma and the two men carry much of the emotional work.
Romance is the whole point, with a love triangle at the center of the plot.
The settings are ordinary and recognizable, from Massachusetts towns to the California coast.
The story unfolds in a contemporary setting, so it feels close to the present day.
The question of love and loss is lasting, though the book feels rooted in its genre moment.
Emma tells her story straightforwardly, and nothing signals a narrator hiding the truth.
Neither man is a villain, so the choice carries real ambiguity rather than a clear right answer.
The settings are sketched economically, with emotion given more space than scenery.
This is a novel, so the dial does not apply.
The perspective is intimate and personal, tied closely to Emma's own feelings.
It reads as a self-contained standalone novel.
The central reveal reshapes the story, though much of the book follows the expected path.
It is more comforting than challenging, even as it deals with grief.
Grief sits at the center, but the book stays emotionally gentle overall.
Longing, grief and love run high, making this an intensely emotional read.
Humor is light and warm rather than broad or biting.
The book is about heartbreak, with almost no violence on the page.
Intimacy is part of the romance, but it is not the focus.
Politics plays no real role in this personal story.
The language is plain and easy to follow throughout.
Emma's feelings color the telling, but the book does not push strong opinions.
The story moves toward a future after loss, though it keeps the past in view.
It believes in love and second chances, and treats that belief sincerely.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is One True Loves right for?
A good fit for adult and mature teen readers who enjoy emotional contemporary romance. It deals with grief and loss and includes some intimacy, though nothing graphic.
It is an easy, absorbing read that asks little of the reader beyond attention.
Grief sits at the center, but the book stays emotionally gentle overall.
Longing, grief and love run high, making this an intensely emotional read.
The book is about heartbreak, with almost no violence on the page.
One True Loves: ideas, characters, themes
After losing her husband and finding a new love, Emma must face what it means to love truly when both men are real and both matter.
- A marriage cut short. Emma and Jesse marry young and build an adventurous life together, which ends abruptly on their first anniversary.
- Coming home. After the loss, Emma leaves her job and returns to Massachusetts to rebuild.
- A second chance. Years later she reconnects with Sam, an old friend, and a new relationship grows into an engagement.
- News that changes everything. Word about Jesse upends her new life and leaves her with two commitments.
- A question of the heart. The story turns on whether Emma can trust her own feelings to decide who her one true love is.
Characters
Emma Blair
Protagonist
A woman who has loved and lost once and must now choose between two relationships.
Jesse Lerner
Emma's first husband
Her high school sweetheart, with whom she built an adventurous early marriage.
Sam Kemper
Emma's fiancé
An old friend who becomes her new love years after the loss.
Themes
What we owe to the people we have promised ourselves to.
How a person rebuilds after losing the life they expected.
Whether a new happiness can be real after a great loss.
How who you are shifts through the relationships you choose.
The weight of deciding when no option is free of pain.
Discussion questions
- Did Emma's choice feel earned, and what would you have wanted her to decide?
- How does the book treat Jesse and Sam fairly, and did you favor one?
- What does the story suggest about whether we have one true love or several?
- How does grief shape the way Emma loves the second time?
- Does the romance genre's familiar shape help or limit this story?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow One True Loves
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked One True Loves
A secrets-driven Dallas romance that favors feeling over surprise
Expiration DatesRebecca SerleA romance built on one clever, high-concept rule
Every Summer AfterCarley FortuneA lakeside second-chance romance that trades freshness for heart
Heart BonesColleen HooverA summer fling with a rip current underneath
Sources: Open Library.
Track One True Loves and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.