Not for the Faint of Heart
by Lex Croucher · 2024
This is a young adult novel, suited to teens and adult readers who enjoy light, funny romance and adventure.
352 pages, about 5.5 to 8 hours.
A queer Robin Hood retelling with jokes, heart, and a stolen healer. 58% taste match
The story
Not for the Faint of Heart is a queer historical young adult romance by Lex Croucher, first published in 2024. It is a feminist retelling that continues the legend of Robin Hood, set in Sherwood Forest in the Middle Ages, with elements of fantasy running through the story. It is Croucher's second book in the queer historical YA romance vein, and it runs to roughly 352 pages.
The story follows Mariel, a young captain of the Merry Men who is eager to measure up to her grandfather, Robin Hood, and Clem, a backwoods healer who wants only to help people. After Mariel's band of outlaws takes Clem captive, a deadly ambush leaves Mariel's father, Jack Hartley, who commands the Merry Men, in enemy hands. Mariel goes after him with Clem beside her, and the two girls are drawn into a wider conflict in the forest, where the Merry Men's place in the world is being questioned. The book blends romance between its two leads with comedy and adventure, and it will suit readers who like fairy-tale and folklore retellings with a lesbian love story at the centre.
Setting
Sherwood Forest (England)
Themes
feminist retellingContinuation novelRetellingRomanceFantasyQueerLesbianHistorical
By the numbers
- The median edition runs 352 pages. Counting about 275 words a page and an adult reading pace of 250 words a minute, that is about 6.5 hours of reading.
- Open Library tracks 3 editions from 2 publishers.
- On reader demand it ranks in the top 62% of the recent releases books in our catalog (1,627 of them).
- Libraries shelve it under Dewey 823.00 and Library of Congress class PZ-0007.00000000.C757 N.
A queer Robin Hood retelling with jokes, heart, and a stolen healer
Croucher takes the Robin Hood legend and hands it to the next generation: Mariel, grumpy captain of the Merry Men, and Clem, the cheerful healer she kidnaps. The premise hooks at once, and a captor and captive who clash in tone make a fun engine for the book. It is very funny and very romantic, though it leans on familiar tropes of the genre, which is where it parts company with my appetite for the strikingly original. The retelling angle and the questioning of the Merry Men's legacy give it some freshness. At 352 pages it is a brisk, adventurous read, driven as much by character as by plot, and best taken as a warm, comic romp.
At 352 pages it is moderate in length for a YA adventure, a little longer than BookWard's taste for tight books.
Captures, ambushes and a rescue mission keep the story moving at a lively clip, close to BookWard's preferred speed.
Reframing Robin Hood's legacy through his granddaughter adds a fresh angle, though the form itself is familiar.
The writing is plain and breezy, built for jokes and momentum rather than ornament.
The quest drives events, but the bond between the two leads is what the book is about.
A found-family adventure with a love story at its centre leans warm and optimistic, a touch sunnier than BookWard's usual.
A straightforward quest-and-rescue shape with no formal experiments, close to BookWard's conventional end.
Comedy is central, from Clem's jokes to the clash of personalities, well above BookWard's comfort with humor.
The war in the wood brings real danger, but the tone stays light and warm.
Fear, doubt and growing love give it real feeling beneath the jokes.
See all 50 dialsEvery position, side by side with this book
Where it lines up
- EndingBookWard 8 · book 8
- Story or ideasBookWard 3 · book 3
- PaceBookWard 8 · book 7
Where it pulls apart
- Familiar tropesBookWard 10 · book 4
- Internal logicBookWard 10 · book 6
- LengthBookWard 1 · book 4
At 352 pages it is moderate in length for a YA adventure, a little longer than BookWard's taste for tight books.
A captain kidnapping a healer is a premise that grabs immediately, which matches BookWard's love of a fast start.
It runs on the internal rules of adventure romance, sound enough for the story without being airtight.
Captures, ambushes and a rescue mission keep the story moving at a lively clip, close to BookWard's preferred speed.
Reframing Robin Hood's legacy through his granddaughter adds a fresh angle, though the form itself is familiar.
Mariel's doubts about her cause and Clem's relentless optimism give both leads real texture, a little short of BookWard's ideal.
Adventure romance of this kind tends toward a satisfying resolution, in line with BookWard's taste for closure.
Warmth and found family sit at the heart of the book, so it is more openly tender than BookWard's restrained taste.
The danger comes from the plot's stakes rather than shock for its own sake, which suits BookWard well.
This is a novel, so the rigor dial does not apply.
Clem's terrible jokes and Mariel's grumpy asides give the book a recognisable comic voice.
This is firmly story-led, built on rescue, romance and adventure rather than argument, as BookWard prefers.
Character and banter carry the telling, so the world is mostly shown in scene, which BookWard likes.
With a rescue quest driving it, the middle has a clear purpose, though the format invites some wandering.
The writing is plain and breezy, built for jokes and momentum rather than ornament.
The quest drives events, but the bond between the two leads is what the book is about.
A found-family adventure with a love story at its centre leans warm and optimistic, a touch sunnier than BookWard's usual.
A straightforward quest-and-rescue shape with no formal experiments, close to BookWard's conventional end.
Comedy is central, from Clem's jokes to the clash of personalities, well above BookWard's comfort with humor.
It is an easy, accessible YA read that asks little of the reader, easier than BookWard's usual.
The story centres on Mariel and Clem, with a few other threads around them, so the view is fairly narrow.
Folklore and fantasy elements run through a legend-based Sherwood, though it stays largely earthy.
The Merry Men band and the wider forest conflict mean more characters than a two-hander, but not a vast roster.
A war in the wood raises the stakes, yet the story stays close to the two leads on their journey.
The quest brings plenty of outward action, balanced by the leads' shifting feelings.
Banter and verbal sparring carry much of the story, which BookWard enjoys.
A queer romance between the two leads sits at the core of the plot, well above BookWard's usual.
Sherwood Forest and the Middle Ages are well-known territory, only lightly unfamiliar.
A medieval setting places it firmly in the past, away from BookWard's present-day lean.
Legend retellings have lasting appeal, though the book's tone is tied to a contemporary YA moment.
Mariel's growing doubt about the Merry Men complicates things, but the book keeps a clear heart.
The forest setting is present but the book puts character and humor ahead of lavish scenery.
An ambush and a captured commander suggest turns in the plot, though romance conventions limit the surprises.
This is a comforting, feel-good read more than a challenging one.
The war in the wood brings real danger, but the tone stays light and warm.
Fear, doubt and growing love give it real feeling beneath the jokes.
The humor is playful and openly comic, leaning broader than dry.
The romance centres on closeness and a shared bed, with the focus on feeling rather than explicit content.
Questions over which side of history the Merry Men stand on bring a political edge without dominating.
Contemporary, jokey language keeps the reading plain and quick.
The comic voice and attitude give the narration a clear point of view.
It looks forward, with a younger generation reconsidering an inherited legacy.
Faith in found family, kindness and doing right runs strongly through the story.
Review written by BookWard, dial version 1, November 2026.
Who is Not for the Faint of Heart right for?
This is a young adult novel, suited to teens and adult readers who enjoy light, funny romance and adventure. It includes fighting, danger and a romance with a shared bed, though the tone stays warm rather than graphic.
It is an easy, accessible YA read that asks little of the reader, easier than BookWard's usual.
The war in the wood brings real danger, but the tone stays light and warm.
Fear, doubt and growing love give it real feeling beneath the jokes.
Not for the Faint of Heart: ideas, characters, themes
Robin Hood's granddaughter must decide whether her family's legend is worth following when she kidnaps a healer who sees the world differently.
- Legacy under pressure. Mariel is desperate to live up to Robin Hood, but the book asks whether the Merry Men still stand on the right side of history.
- Opposites thrown together. Grumpy Mariel and relentlessly cheerful Clem are forced into close quarters, which drives both the comedy and the romance.
- A rescue mission. When Mariel's father Jack Hartley is captured in an ambush, she sets out to get him back with Clem in tow.
- A forest at war. The wood is divided, and the conflict raises questions about who the outlaws really protect.
- Found family. The ramshackle band of outlaws and the ties that form around the two leads are a warm core of the story.
Characters
Mariel
Captain of the Merry Men
A newly blooded and perpetually grumpy captain eager to live up to her grandfather Robin Hood.
Clem
Backwoods healer
A too-perky healer known for new-fangled cures who wants to help people and tells relentlessly terrible jokes.
Jack Hartley
Commander of the Merry Men
Mariel's father, whose capture in an ambush sets the rescue quest in motion.
Robin Hood
Legendary grandfather
The famed outlaw whose legacy Mariel feels she must measure up to.
Themes
Living up to, or breaking from, the expectations of a famous family.
The bonds that form between people thrown together by circumstance.
Questioning whether an old cause still serves the people it claims to protect.
How two very different people grow closer through shared danger.
The contrast between healing people and fighting for them.
Discussion questions
- Does Mariel's devotion to her grandfather's legacy help or hold her back?
- How do Clem's jokes and optimism change the people around her?
- What makes a retelling of a famous legend feel fresh?
- When should a cause be questioned instead of followed?
- How does the book balance humor with real danger?
Personalize your Book Companion
This is the general edition. In BookWard, the Companion is written for you: your reading profile, your notes, and spoiler-safe to the page you are on.
Buy, listen or borrow Not for the Faint of Heart
Each link opens a search for this book on that store, in a new tab.
Read on a device
Borrow
Reviews and community
If you liked Not for the Faint of Heart
A cozy romantasy where the groom is a horse by day
Agnes Aubert's Mystical Cat ShelterHeather FawcettA type-A cat rescuer meets a failed Dark Lord in cozy 1920s Montreal
Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain AnymoreEmily KrempholtzA reformed villain, a prickly alchemist, and a town worth saving
Ella EnchantedGail Carson LevineA Cinderella retelling where obedience is the curse, and Ella fights back
Sources: Open Library.
Track Not for the Faint of Heart and find your next favorite
Add it to your shelf, rate what you have read, and BookWard will recommend what fits you.
Free to start. No credit card needed.